We’re still working out how we can best use the powerful Graduate Outcomes dataset in understanding higher education outcomes. David Kernohan plots one option.
This article is more than 5 years old

Graduate Outcomes is still an experimental dataset.
Its novelty means that is difficult to talk meaningfully about trends – we simply don’t know what an unusual year looks like, an issue compounded by the fact that this second year of data (2018-19 graduates, 15 months on) is very clearly an unusual year, and the first year of a data collection exercise is always an unusual year.
HESA published a detailed examination of the impacts of the pandemic on graduate outcomes last week, and I wrote it up over on Wonk Corner. Bearing in mind the headline drop in graduate full-time employment, I thought – with one eye on a reanimated TEF and an OfS outcomes measure consultation – I’d take a look at some of the ways graduate outcomes may be used in future.
The three “reflective” questions – on activity utilising what you have learned, fit of current activity with future plans, and whether activity feels “meaningful” – feel a little like asking graduates how satisfied they are with the outcome of their higher education experience. As we already ask final year students specifically about course and provider experience in the National Student Survey, I wondered whether the NSS predicts reflective question responses.
At a top level, at least – we don’t get the reflective questions by subject area and provider – there doesn’t appear to be a relationship. Student satisfaction (I’m using question 27 % agree for 2019) and graduate satisfaction (I’m using “I’m using what I learnt during my studies in my current activity” % agree for 2018-19) don’t correlate.
There’s a lot in this dashboard – you can easily look at any NSS question via the filter at the bottom, or look only at employed graduates using the controls at the top. The independence of these two variables might well be at the root of the DfE concerns about the national student survey – or reflect the traditional criticism that “satisfied” students don’t become fulfilled graduates. Use the provider highlight box at the bottom – or the usual filters by group and region are there (alternative and FE are filtered out by default but you can easily add them back).
If we are going to use “highly skilled employment” as a measure of quality (even in the bastardised version linked to the nine top SOC groups that is common in higher education), the debate is very quickly going to turn to which subject area within a provider is contributing to a low score. It’s not simple to get this information from the HESA data, but here’s one way you might approach it.
First of all – which subjects tend to lead to employment of any sort? This chart defaults to look sector-wide, but you can use the provider filter to check how you are doing against that baseline.
We can see, for instance, that creative arts graduates are more likely to work part-time – an issue I’ve been over in detail on the site before. This feature of choosing to make your way as a creative professional has an impact on both salary and reported job skill level, and it is important to distinguish employment market effects from subject of study effects. A sensible output measure (one that isn’t based on LEO for example) would take this into account.
Regionality is another factor – OfS has already taken a look at this, but there is a lot more nuance to be found if you work through graduate outcomes. For instance, what industry do your graduates tend to work in? Is it a valuable local industry that is not flattered by SOC classifications? Here’s a map:
We don’t get the impacts of industry on skill level at a provider and subject level – but even a look by provider offers a few hints.
Couple this with a SIC/SOC plot for the whole sector (what skill level – SOC – do graduates working in a particular industry – SIC – have?) and we’re starting to see patterns. If your provider offers courses that prepare graduates for careers in agriculture, accommodation, logistics, or trade you may have a problem.
Level 4 and Level 5 technical qualifications, anyone? Let’s hope we don’t use these output metrics to assess the quality of those new courses.
Graduate outcomes is a rich dataset, but not a mature one. We are still getting a feel for what normal looks like, and response rates are not quite as high as we’d hoped. There’s still bits that I’d like to get at that aren’t published – for instance, our question above would best be answered by a version of this graph by provider:
It is equally possible, however, that as we get to know the data set we might find that this isn’t the issue we are interested in. Even well established releases are modified on occasion to take account of new pre-occupations.

David Kernohan | Data | 9/11/26

David Kernohan | Data | 6/11/26

David Kernohan | Data | 16/09/26

David Kernohan | Data | 18/08/26

David Kernohan | Data | 13/08/26

David Kernohan | Data | 9/07/26