Gary Guadagnolo explains why deliberately taking a step into the world of the fantastical can breathe life into universities’ strategic planning conversations this autumn
This article is more than 5 years old

It seems like an eternity ago, but back in June I hosted a session at Wonkfest entitled “The Crowdsourced University”.
I challenged 100+ attendees to prepare for the autumn term by designing a university from the ground up, leveraging what we’ve learnt about student and staff preferences and experiences in the wake of the pandemic. What old albatrosses should we leave behind, and what bold decisions might we make moving forward?
Over the course of an hour, session participants responded to fifteen multiple-choice prompts about the mission, strategy, physical footprint, academic portfolio, and enrollment ambitions of “Crowdsourced U”. For each question, the answer with the most votes determined the direction of travel for the fledgling institution.
For example: You want Crowdsourced U to tackle issues of diversity, equity, and inclusion head-on. Rather than splitting efforts, you decide to plant your flag in the ground on one of the following issues. Which do you choose?
Three sector leaders joined me on the virtual stage to discuss the implications of the collective decision-making: Helen Watson, Registrar and Secretary at Goldsmiths; Aash Khadia, Director of Planning at University of Leicester; and Mark Ferrar, CIO at Newcastle University.
Just what kind of university did we create? Here are the brochure highlights, with indications of the percentage of session attendees who tipped the university in that particular direction. You can also download the questions in full via the link at the bottom of this article.
I won’t blame you if you are sceptical about debating strategic and operational decisions for a non-existent university, given the many priorities that are undoubtedly lurking in your inbox. But intentionally stepping away from the tyranny of the urgent can help you avoid blind spots when it comes to thinking about the future of your own institution.
These blind spots tempt leaders to focus disproportionally on current and internal information when planning for the future. As a result, they tend to imagine the future will look fairly like their present context.
One way to combat this bias is to create and engage with future scenarios that are radically different from the present. The point is not to nitpick what is or isn’t feasible in those scenarios, but to step outside day-to-day concerns to consider what it would take to succeed in that future world. In these exercises, it’s helpful to ask, “Is this a future that I would want to help create? What therefore should be done—or not done?” That approach—looking beyond the here and now—was at the heart of the Crowdsourced U exercise.
If you’d like to see a compelling example of this future visioning in action, check out Stanford University’s Stanford2025. The university ran the experiment several years ago to consider possible directions that undergraduate education might take by 2100. Several of the ideas fancifully proposed in Stanford2025 as possible by the end of the century are already close to reality only a decade later (e.g. a lifelong learner model).
For the purposes of Crowdsourced U, while tapping into the vox populi admittedly veered us away from the boldest possible reimagining of a university, the real benefit of the exercise came through in the debate about trade offs.
In a world of limited resources, what does it mean to say “no” to otherwise good ideas – to prioritise eliminating attainment and job placement gaps amongst students of colour over efforts to increase staff diversity, for example?
As the results of the polling came in, our Crowdsourced U panellists noted a number of these tensions. They merit consideration in your own institutional contexts this autumn, too.
Exercises like the one we undertook with Crowdsourced U need to have a tangible impact on your present context. In other words, when embarking into future scenarios, don’t forget to book a return trip.
Even in the sixty minutes we spent building Crowdsourced U, participants surfaced the right kind of questions to spark reflection:
Alas, I don’t have all those answers for your institution. But you or a colleague might – so don’t be afraid to take a step outside of your comfort zone and day-to-day priorities and engage in some future visioning. Use the questions linked below or make up your own. Have another good idea for sparking this kind of strategic imagination? Feel free to share in the comments.
This article is published in association with EAB.

Mark Andrews | Comment | 17/11/26

Doug Specht | Comment | 17/11/26

Andy Mycock | Comment | 16/11/26

Matt Offord | Comment | 13/11/26

Hugh Jones | Comment | 13/11/26

Shahenda Shehata | Comment | 12/11/26