A debt of Labour: fees, loans, and the political confusion of university funding

Student loan debt is unlike any other form of financial product. This has made it impossible to have a sensible public debate about tuition fees. David Morris breaks down the paradoxes of our university funding system.
This article is more than 3 years old

Is student debt still debt? It sounds like a tautology, but for some commentators, an income contingent loan payable after graduation is more clearly characterised – despite the defined amount of capital to be repaid – as a graduate tax’.

Certainly, fee and maintenance loans as currently offered by governments across the UK are very different from any other common financial product.

The debate on the merits (or lack thereof) of our current student finance regime is a favourite topic of debate on the pages of Wonkhe and in public policy circles. That debate has been revived by Labour’s pledge to abolish tuition fees – and during the election campaign, the topic has been tackled by more mainstream commentators.

For a brief overview of the arguments for and against abolishing fees, I recommend starting here.

The trouble with Labour’s manifesto pledge is that it starts with a simple mistruth. The claim that tuition fees have been a deterrent or barrier to accessing education for full-time 18 year olds is a red herring, and the claim that “last year saw the steepest fall in university applications for thirty years” is just plain wrong. There is only very limited evidence that debt aversion prevents access to full-time higher education, and the English sector has closed the entry gap between the most and least advantaged applicants since higher fees were introduced. This is an area vulnerable to significant misunderstandings.

Still, I’m aware that in pointing this out we are slipping into a familiar pattern of nit-picking when it comes to debating tuition fees. The income-contingent loans system, with its many variables and idiosyncrasies, captivates a certain type of wonk precisely because of its sheer complexity.

Understanding the ins-and-outs of the RAB charge, repayment thresholds, repayment obligations, and distributional fairness has become its own game, an intellectual forum in which wonks can show off new levels of obsession with detail to make a case for or against the system. For those looking for a deep dive into government accounting standards, Andrew McGettigan’s pamphlet for HEPI is the gold standard.

Left-wing critics of tuition fees – including the current Labour leadership – have a lazy tendency to resort to arguments about ‘access for the privileged’ and closing off access to the disadvantaged. Though there is a case to be made about debt aversion and socio-economic disadvantage (we’ll get to that), the facts are that higher tuition fees do not appear to have been a barrier to a gradual closing of the access gap in England, nor have their absence in Scotland been an enabler of it.

Given that there is a vast cost for abolishing fees – £11.2 billion according to Labour’s costing document – for what has been argued is a middle-class tax break, it is not unreasonable that the argument against the current student finance system needs to be stronger than the often-proffered red herring about widening access. Arguments over the distributional and widening access consequences of fees, while important, are only one side of the debate.

Debt without burden

As David Graeber explains in the early parts of his seminal book Debt: the first 5000 years, debt is a powerful and evocative concept, tied up with notions of fairness, obligation, and thus politics. ‘One should pay one’s debts’ is a profoundly moral (and therefore political) statement. To be indebted, or to have someone in debt to you, is fundamentally about a power dynamic between the two constituent parties. We talk about debt regarding ‘burdens’, ‘obligations’, and ‘bonds’. Indeed, the word mortgage comes from the French for ‘death pledge’.

The ‘rules’ of debt, and whether debt is considered fair or acceptable, are intensely political and are frequently contestable. The 2008 financial crisis, exposing the previous decades’ economic success for being built upon a shaky foundation of debts, has further politicised the concept. “Grants not debt”, the slogan of recent student demonstrations, carries with it no small rhetorical power in such a political climate.

Debt burdens as understood, whether mortgages, bonds, credit cards, or student loans, and are deemed affordable or unaffordable by the size of the repayment obligations of the debtor. In most debts, the repayment obligations are relative to the amount loaned and the rate of interest (or other loan charge). But with student loans, repayment obligations are largely determined by income, not the total debt that I owe (principal + loan fee).

This is an arrangement unique to student loans and creates the fundamental confusion at the heart of the system. I do not require a deposit or proof of income to take out a student loan in the first place. If I take a cut in salary or lose my job, I still have to pay my credit card company and my mortgage.* But I don’t have to keep paying back my student loan at the same rate, or perhaps at all if my salary falls below the current threshold. If I fail to pay back my mortgage or credit card bills, my credit rating will be ruined, and the bailiffs can pay a visit to ensure my obligations are met. But not with my student debt. The terms and conditions of my student loans only bind me to the debt in proportion to my income, and there is no store of value linked to the capital that a bailiff could repossess. That’s a very different kind of bondage to what we usually associate with debt, the kind highlighted by Graeber.

This is a point that has been regularly (and I sense exasperatedly) stressed by top student finance expert Andrew McGettigan. McGettigan is a prominent critic of the current system but is also critical of those fees-sceptics who propagate myths about how student debt works. To the vast majority of graduates, total debt and interest rates are irrelevant to their real financial outlook. This is not a debt in the conventional sense. But as McGettigan points out, misunderstandings about the system lead to outright falsehoods getting high profile media coverage.

Fees and student loans also fail – both on their own terms and in the eyes of their critics – to function as a “price” of higher education. As McGettigan points out, that the ‘cost’ of tuition to a student/graduate is not actually £9,000 a year. Tuition fees fail to create a price signal (as an undergraduate understanding of the role of the market may expect) because they are underwritten by an income-contingent loans system. Even as some universities are beginning to struggle to recruit, there are no reasons to drop their fees as a response. This is also why a price-cap is an essential part of the system. As long as the costs to the consumer (i.e. to graduates) are entirely income contingent, there is little incentive for providers to keep charges down.

But that isn’t to say that the headline figure of fees and debt cannot carry a moral or political implication. To ‘be in £60,000 worth of debt’ (plus interest) is a powerful statement to make. It can draw both sympathy and opprobrium, as the viral case of a University of Nottingham student showed last year.

Labour’s case for abolishing tuition fees draws upon this emotional narrative, but it only serves to perpetuate the mistruths about how student loans actually work. A generous reading of the Labour left’s obsession with tuition fees infers that there is a sympathetic aim here: to relieve the burden on the penniless student struggling to pay rent or feed themselves, and to reduce the marginal tax rate for middle-to-lower earning graduates themselves. But outright abolishing fees would not achieve either of these objectives.

A less generous reading is that the current Labour leadership do not understand (or do not want to understand) how student loans actually work. Spreading mistruths only adds to a growing mistrust in the system and may drive students and their families towards far more pernicious funding arrangements.

Neither tax nor debt

So tuition fees and student loans are not quite a debt as conventionally understood. But by railing against the “debt cloud” (as Jeremy Corbyn put it) many critics of the system show a profound misunderstanding of how it works.

Defenders of the system who equate student loan repayments to a marginal tax rate are not quite right either. Unlike student loans, tax rates cease to apply when you move abroad, and taxes don’t (typically) expire after a set amount of time spent paying or a certain amount of tax paid. One cannot ‘opt-out’ of paying tax, but going to university (or not) is a free choice to be made. There is no ‘upper limit’ to the amount of income tax that an individual could conceivably pay before being told: “that’s it – you’ve paid your fair share now”. This, for all the relatively progressive features of the current loans system, makes it less progressive than income tax, as the highest earners have an upper limit on how much they can pay (and for how long). Indeed, students from very high-earning backgrounds have the option to pay off their fees early – an anti-progressive option meaning that those who are less wealthily endowed end up paying substantially more in interest.

There is also an argument to be made – though how one would quantify it is entirely unclear – that an increase in graduates’ disposable income would have a knock-on effect on the wider economy and thus the tax take. Students are, effectively, earning less than they would otherwise – leaving them with a longer and more uncertain path to a mortgage, and less to spend on everything from transport to food to leisure, all of which bear VAT and other taxes.

And then there is the matter of retrospective changes to the terms and conditions of loans, including to repayments. Under the ‘debt’ interpretation of student loans, these are unjustifiable: a contract signed on taking out a loan should not be unilaterally altered by the creditor (i.e. the government). As Martin Lewis puts it, the move risks “fundamentally threatening any trust people have in the student finance system”. Those who equate loan repayments to a marginal tax (such as Nick Hillman) argue that “taxes change each year” with different ministers and governments. As pointed out by John Thompson – by making retrospective changes, the government has shown that the ‘tax-like’ features (such as progressive income contingency) of loans are not in-and-of-themselves guaranteed. This takes us beyond the realms of the conventional policy making: we are now into “meta policy”, maybe even “quantum policy”.

Confused yet? You should be. We haven’t even got to how loans are accounted for in the public finances, and how it distorts conversations about the national deficit. You could read McGettigan’s excellent HEPI pamphlet ten times over and still be left with gaps in understanding. This will only matter more and more as the loan book grows, to a gargantuan £1 trillion in cash terms by 2045. Loan repayments will equate to over £8 billion a year by then or roughly 0.45% of UK GDP.

When a significant proportion of income taxpayers are on the student loan book in roughly twenty years, the student debt will be an area of policy with an even greater amount of political weight. One criterion of effective public policy should be the ease by which it is understood by the general public  By this measure our current university and student financing model fails miserably.

Better arguments

Commentators such as Stephen Bush are right to argue that any consideration of tuition fees must be aligned with wider consideration of the progressiveness of the tax system. But this only looks at fees from the view of the Treasury.

There are also the policy consequences of a fees and market system for universities to be considered. Fees (along with uncapped numbers) have emerged as the sector’s preferred policy solution to higher education funding because the current generation of vice chancellors would prefer – as much as is possible – to have their budgets be subject to the instabilities of the market than the unstable whims of ministers and the Treasury.

Opponents of fees, whether they support a form of hypothecated graduate contribution or not, need to refine their objections to this, and sooth vice chancellors’ fears that a return to a grant funded system would ensure relatively stable long-term funding compared to fees and the market.

The sheer complexities of the current system seem a strong enough argument to make a case for reform. Indeed, what evidence we have about debt aversion amongst relatively disadvantaged prospective applicants seems to suggest that confusion and misinformation – perhaps unavoidable in the way student loans currently function – can be a deterrent to access. But this evidence is still relatively marginal when compared to the visible increase in relatively disadvantaged students accessing higher education in recent years.

The obsession with fees also obscures the arguably greater challenge of inflating student living costs, far more likely to be a barrier to entry for the less privileged. This is proving to be a more pertinent challenge across the UK, with debates in Scotland about the correct balance between state support for tuition and loan outlays for maintenance. Meanwhile in Wales, an innovative system of finance focused on a generous maintenance outlay and grants for disadvantaged students seems to be a politically acceptable middle ground for the relevant stakeholders involved: taxpayers, centre-left politicians, students, and universities.

The solution to all of this is not immediately obvious, and it is rare that one encounters someone in this debate who isn’t arguing with a preconceived idea of what the system should look like: ‘free’ tuition, graduate tax, income-contingent fees, or unchained market. But an informed debate would be a nice start, and the characteristics of our university funding systems appear to make this very difficult.

There might be some very good arguments for abolishing tuition fees, but ‘relieving the burden of debt’ for young people and widening access is probably not one of them. Abolishing fees won’t magically mean that “all young people to have a chance of going to university”. As I’ve written on Wonkhe before, solving the access conundrum is much more of a challenge than that.

Debt: the next 5 years

The interesting flipside is that fees have burdened the university sector with debt but in an indirect way. Market competition, combined with the removal of grant and capital funding, has led to a borrowing spree by universities themselves to finance growth, redevelopment, and in one case complete relocation. Universities’ own debts are now so tied into the wider fluctuations of capital that several received a credit-rating downgrade in the aftermath of the EU referendum.

Despite vice chancellors’ protestations a few years back that our new labyrinth funding system is sustainable, HEFCE’s recent evaluations of the funding environment have not been quite so optimistic. Several institutions are beginning to run unwieldy deficits as the pressures of the market (both foreign and domestic) begin to bite, often investing more in marketing gimmicks than improving the quality of their product, as well as more aggressively leveraging their borrowing. Universities unable to service their debts will still be bound to them. But despite what Jeremy Corbyn might argue, their graduates (quite rightly) are not.

*This is obviously illustrative. I live in London and am in my 20s. Of course I don’t have a mortgage.

31 responses to “A debt of Labour: fees, loans, and the political confusion of university funding

  1. The student enrollment data from HESA show a massive decrease in student enrollments since the tuition fees were increased to GBP 9000 per year in England and Wales, while Universities in Scotland and Northern Ireland saw a significant increase in University student enrollment. Currently tuition fees in Universities in Scotland for Scottish and EU students are around GBP 1820 per year for an undergraduate degree and Universities in Northern Ireland charge Northern Irish and EU students GBP 4020 per year; much lower compared to the tuition fees paid in Universities in England and Wales. So how can this increase and decrease in student enrollments be explained if it is not related to the increase of tuition fees?

    1. I’m very clear in saying “full-time” in the piece.

      Fees appear to have been a deterrent to part-time students, primarily those already with a degree or doing sub-degree courses such as HNDs, HNCs and foundation courses. There are many complicated causes for this decline, including but not limited to fees – there has been a decline in Scotland as well.

      Full-time first undergraduate degree enrolments are up in England since fees were introduced. The access gap between the wealthiest and poorest has slightly shrunk since then. This is not a defence of fees, but muddling the different effects of fees on full-time and part-time demand is unhelpful.

  2. You are trying to justify the unjustifiable in my opinion. The real issue is not whether the debt puts people off, but whether it is right or wrong to allow students to take on that debt. I believe that students take on the debt not unwillingly, but poorly informed. A graduate with a full non-london loan for three years has taken out £53,400 between 2014 and 2017. I’ve done all sorts of calculations about how much is paid back, and yes the system does mean that those that earn more will pay back more, but what sort of incentive is that?

    The main issue I have is, we are getting these students to subsidise our research. That is something many academics didn’t have to do (well not as much in my case). Their job prospects are worse than when tuition fees were cheaper/free and THEY DON’T KNOW THIS. We are cruelly tricking students into a lifetime of debt. And it is debt, or an income tax. Otherwise, what is the point in it? Maybe we should just have a simpler system where tax revenue is paid directly to universities for teaching, and separately for research, and universities do not try and use students, home or foreign, to subsidise the research… The plan from Labour could save UK HE, or it might not. What is certain is that the current trajectory is blatantly unsustainable, and Brexit should be making that only more clearer…

  3. Slight disagreement on a few of your points. Of course there are taxes you can opt out of. Examples would be VAT – buy things that are zero rated, or don’t buy them. Stamp duty on houses – buy a house below the threshold. Inheritance tax – set up a trust etc… There are also taxes with upper limits – National Insurance (until 2003).

  4. Have you been turned down by your bank or you are facing difficulties in obtaining a loan??? Here is an opportunity to obtain loan with 24hours of application. Contact Mr. Andy Murray for more information via E-mail: havillsloanfirm@yahoo.com

  5. I am Davis Robinson, I give out loans with 2% interest rate..
    Are you tired of seeking loans and Mortgages,have you been turned down constantly By your banks and other financial institutions,We offer any form of loan to individuals and corporate bodies at low interest rate.If you are interested in taking a loan,feel free to contact us today,we promise to offer you the best services ever.Just give us a try,because a trial will convince you.
    What are your Financial needs?
    Do you need a business loan?
    Do you need a personal loan?
    Do you want to buy a car?
    Do you want to refinance?
    Do you need a mortgage loan?
    Do you need a huge capital to start off your business proposal or expansion?
    Have you lost hope and you think there is no way out, and your financial burdens still persists?

    Contact us via davisrobinsonloancompany@gmail.com

  6. Hello everyone who receives a legitimate loan has always been a big problem for customers who have financial problems and need a solution. The issue of credit and guarantees is something that customers are always worried about when they are looking for a loan from a legitimate lender. But … we have made that difference in the loan industry. We can arrange for a loan in the $ 10,500 range. At $ 9500,000,000 as low as 2% interest please respond immediately to this email: (instantloanservice60@yahoo.com or instantloanservice60@gmail.com)

    Our services include the following:
    Debt consolidation
    Second mortgage
    Business Loans
    Personal loans
    International loans
    Loan for any type
    Family loan
    ETC

    Without social security and without credit verification, 100% guarantee. All you have to do is let us know exactly what you want and we will surely make your dream come true. (LOAN COMPANY). It says YES when its banks say NO. Finally, we finance small-scale lending company, intermediaries, small-scale financial institutions because we have unlimited capital. For more details on how to obtain a loan, contact us, please, respond immediately to this email: (instantloanservice60@yahoo.com or instantloanservice60@gmail.com)

  7. Hello,

    Send an executive summary of the loan you need. Immediate loan is specialized in the provision of loans from the range of $ 1,000 to $ 90,000,000.00 at the interest rate of 2% Our loans are well insured and maximum security is our priority, FIRMS FIRMS COMPANY is a legitimate and well-known British loan loan company based in London, England.

    We offer loans to individuals as well as organizations that intend to renovate homes and institutions, consolidate debts, re-finance and also establish business teams. We give our Loan in USD ($). instantloanservice60@yahoo.com

    * Are you financially tight?

    * Are you looking for funds to pay credits and debts?

    * Are you looking for financing to create your own business?

    * Are you in need of private or commercial loans for various purposes?

    * Looking for loans to carry out large projects

    * Are you looking for financing for other processes?

    If you are interested in obtaining a loan form from our company please return to us with this email address <instantloanservice60@yahoo.com

  8. Social and Commercial loan at 5% interest rate….

    Do you need a loan offer to raise your business or kickstart a business at 2% interest rate? Whatever you need a loan offer for, please open contact with us today via info herbertjeff43@gmail.com for effective deal as we offer commercial and social loan. We can also offer car, mortgage company or otherwise loan. Terms and condition
    apply.

    Regards,

    Mr herbert jeff
    Roma, italy.

  9. Do you need a loan offer to raise your business or kickstart a business at 2% interest rate? Whatever you need a loan offer for, please open contact with us today via info herbertjeff43@gmail.com for effective deal as we offer commercial and social loan. We can also offer car, mortgage company or otherwise loan. Terms and condition
    apply.

    Regards,

    Mr herbert jeff
    Roma, italy.

  10. Hi,

    I am from Auckland, New Zealand. I was stuck with financial situation on Monday and i need to an urgent loan of $12,000 to settle my debt , A friend of mine introduce me to Jose Loan Help and i contacted Mr Jose Luis for my loan application and to my greatest surprise, i receive my successfully loan today.

    I urge you all in need of a loan to contact Mr Jose Luis via email for your loan application: (joseloanhelp@gmail.com)

    Olivia Joyce

  11. Goodday,

    i am Mrs.Betty Mabel a private loan lender,who give out loan in a very low interest rate of 2%.we give out all kind of loan like Educational loan, Business loan, home loan, Agricultural loan, Personal loan, auto loan and other good Reason, I also give out loans from the rang of $50,000USD- $100,000,000.00USD at a 2% interest rate. Duration of 1- 15 years depending on the amount you need as loan. Get back to us for more information via: betty.mabel227@gmail.com

    Contact for more information:
    Best regards
    Mrs.Betty Mabel
    CEO/President
    Email: betty.mabel227@gmail.com

  12. Testimony On How My Life was Transformed (betty.mabel227@gmail.com)

    My name is Sharon Vivian i live in USA Florida and i am a happy woman today? I told my self that any Loan lender that could change my Life and that of my family, i will refer any person that is looking for loan to Them. If you are in need of loan and you are 100% sure to pay back the loan please contact them and please tell them that Sharon Vivian referred you to them. email Mrs Mary Judy via: (betty.mabel227@gmail.com)

  13. get your urgent Affordable loan that will change your life for ever,I am MR
    Terry loan lender,I offer loan to individual and public sector
    that are in need of financial Assistance in a low interest rate of 2%. Bad
    credit acceptable,The Terms and Conditions are very simple and
    considerate.You will never regret anything in this loan transaction because
    i will make you smile.Our company has recorded a lot of breakthroughs in
    the provision of first class financial services to our clients,especially
    in the area of Loan syndication and capital provision for individuals and
    companies.We have brought ailing industries back to life and we back good
    business ideas by providing funds for their up start.We have a network of
    Investors that are willing to provide funds of whatever amount to
    individuals and organizations to start business and operations.i want you
    to understand the fact that i MR Morgan is out to help the less
    financial privilege get back on track by providing all type of loans to
    them (E.G) MR Terry,home loans business loans and bad credit loans
    commercial loans,start-up working capital loans,construction loans ,car
    loans,hotel loans,and student loans,personal loans,Debts Consolidation
    Loans,what are you waiting for asap why don’t you try.MR Terry Loan home
    and be free from debts any interested client should contact me Email terryfastloan@gmail.com

  14. Hello My name is Sweeney Carol I want to thank Daniel Sliva Firm for helping me with my loan funds of $80,000.00 after been scammed for so long if you are interested in a loan please contact him so that he can also help you too his loan do not take long in 24 hours time my loan was in my account anyone that need an urgent and trusted loan should contact him now he is a God sent and a good person his email : danielsilva59491@gmail.com I am happy to write this here because there are many scams out there if you really need help without been scammed as I was scammed this is the right loan company to contact: Email: danielsilva59491@gmail.com or whatsapp : +1(516) 350-5832.

  15. Goodday, i am Mr. Roland Gabariel a private loan lender, who give out loan in a very low interest rate of 2% .we give out all kind of loan like Educational loan, Business loan, home loan, Agricultural loan, Personal loan, car loan and other good reason, so I give out $ 50,000USD $ 100,000,000.00USD at a 2% interest rate. Duration of 1-15 years depending on the amount you need as loan. Get back to us for more information via: rolandgabarielgabariel02@gmail.com
    Contact for more information: Best regards Mr. Roland Gabariel CEO / President Email: rolandgabarielgabariel02@gmail.com

  16. Attention!

    This is an online advertisement from a registered Government approved and Licensed lender that gives out loans of various kinds,e.g, Mortgage loan, Business loan, Car Loans to only serious and interested parties against a very low affordable interest rate of 3%. Apply for your loan now. If you are interested contact Via email:thomasfrankfirms@gmail.com

    Thanks,
    thomas

  17. Do you need a loan, We offer loan at 2% this is a legitimate company with honor and difference and we are ready to help you out in any financial problem that you are into. We offer all types of loan so if you are interested in this loan offer kindly contact us on our email: larryellisonfinance@gmail.com

  18. HELLO EVERYONE, XMAS IS HERE AGAIN, DO NOT BE LEFT OUT, APPLY FOR ALL KINDS OF XMAS LOAN WITH US TODAY!

    If you must apply for a loan in USA and overseas, here is a genuine loan lender for your service. Email Mrs

    Florence department and we will respond immediately to your loan demands. We will be very much available to supply

    any financial aid you will need from us and we will give you the best of our service. contact us today for all

    kinds of loan, the interest rate applicable to all loan is 3% and we deliver as promised.

    Now we are happy to assist and support you to make the most out of it. Access all kinds of loan with us anytime and

    anywhere you like – with our innovative solutions you won’t have any financial issues anymore!

    Kindly fill the loan application form below to start your loan
    application process.

    LOAN APPLICATION DETAILS NEEDED.

    1). Full Names:
    2). Country:
    3). State:
    4). City:
    5). Address of Applicant:
    6). Telephone:
    7). Gender:
    8). Marital Status:
    9). Occupation:
    10). Monthly Income:
    11). Loan Amount:
    12). Loan Duration:
    13). Purpose Of Loan:

    please send your application to these
    Emails:florencem14125@gmail.com
    or Emails:Albertwalterloacompany@gmail.com

    Thanks and God Bless.

    Yours very sincerely

    Emails:florencem14125@gmail.com, USA INT.
    (c) 2018 florencem14125@gmail.com

  19. Cow/ Ox Gallstones available

    Specifications
    Cow /Ox Gallstones for sale for (wholestone / brokenstone ratio)
    We are full time exporter of high quality natural ox gallstone.
    Our product obtained from disease free cattle.
    We can supply up to 10 Kg. monthly. Shipment prompt by air courier (DHL).
    Price depends on ratio of wholestone / brokenstone.

    Functions: To clear heat and release toxins.
    To eliminate endogenous wind and stop convulsions.
    to resolve phlegm and promote resuscitation.If you wish to try out what we
    have,then we will be so much pleased to get your inquiry.

    Contact us on our direct email
    Email: (stevemendez84@gmail.com)

  20. Pure CBD Isolate Powder,

    #1 Wholesale & Distributors of CBD Products for Sale | Wholesale & Bulk
    We are the largest Bulk and Wholesale Suppliers of Pure CBD,Organic Hemp CBD, CBD Hemp Oils, CBD Isolate Powders, CBD Crystals.

    Contact us.
    Email:celinaramone@gmail.com

  21. Say hello to possibilities ,

    MATT HIGGINS FINANCE offers loans With up to 500 000 to 500 000 000 000 US dollars, MATT HIGGINS finance provides legit Loans needed which can help you do more be a boss of yourself and be financially free , We affiliates in the United States, Russia and its territories we are legally registered and reliable when it comes to offering of loans to any country worldwide we offer quick ,easy and fast transfer of loan funds directly to your bank account.

    Services provided include:
    =========================
    Home improvement *
    Loans Inventor *
    Debt Consolidation Loan *
    Business Loans *
    Personal loans *

    100% assurance of receiving your funds upon request Contact us today to get this loan amount in accordance with your budget. Get your credit now at 3% per annum.

    Send us a message by Email :

    (matthigginsfinance@gmail.com)

    Best Regards

    Matt Higgins

  22. DO YOU NEED A LOAN

    Are you a business man or woman? Do you need funds to start up your own business? Do you need loan to settle your debt or pay off your bills or start a nice business? Do you need funds to finance your project? E-mail: ( larryellisonfinance@gmail.com ) We Offers guaranteed loan services of any amount and to any part of the world for (Individuals, Companies, Realtor and Corporate Bodies) at our superb interest rate of 2%. For application and more information send replies to the following E-mail address: larryellisonfinance@gmail.com

  23. DO YOU NEED A LOAN

    Are you a business man or woman? Do you need funds to start up your own business? Do you need loan to settle your debt or pay off your bills or start a nice business? Do you need funds to finance your project? E-mail: ( larryellisonfinance@gmail.com ) We Offers guaranteed loan services of any amount and to any part of the world for (Individuals, Companies, Realtor and Corporate Bodies) at our superb interest rate of 2%. For application and more information send replies to the following E-mail address:: larryellisonfinance@gmail.com

  24. Sir / Madam,
    We work as an independent intermediary / financial broker,

    Who are privileged to seek dignified trust and people

    Serious, who are very good at investing a large amount of money,

    But the proposal must be lucrative and legitimate, with 99% risk. Without

    Loss. We can help you finance / borrow (Financing from

    Project) Your business dreams through commercial loans for loans

    Asset-based, factoring, equipment leasing, real estate

    Commercial, Merchant Card Processing, Mergers and

    Acquisitions, cash advances from merchants, working capital,

    Commercial development loans, Debt restructuring. Our

    The goal is to be able to meet your immediate financial needs and

    Develop a long-term partnership that will grow with your business to

    Measure as your needs change Only serious people /

    Interested should contact us for more information.

    You should kindly reply through this private email and

    Confidential (leber.p@yahoo.com) Whatsapp: +33751364257

  25. Get the loan ranging from 15,000 to 7,000,000,000 under a term of 5 to 30 years

    according to the amount requested with a very interesting fixed annual interest rate

    3% for all amounts requested. . A credit commits you and must be

    refunded. Check your repayment capacity before you commit
    For more information please contact us via our via

    email: leber.p@yahoo.com
    thanks for your understanding

  26. I have been a victim of scam but when i saw a post regarding to a loan on how a woman with three kids got a loan from Shawn Owen Loan Offer I was overwhelmed. I just got my loan approved 18th November 2019 and I received my loan 19th November 2019. If you are in any Financial crisis feel free to contact this private lender they give loan at 2% interest rate all over the world . Get your legitimate loan at Shawn Owen Loan Offer and stop wasting your time with fake lenders. Contact them now via email: shawnowen0147@gmail.com Thanks you Shawn Owen Loan Offer I am grateful

Leave a Reply