Daniel Sokol and Bradley Talbot have come across a fair number of student complaints – and think that universities are often making derisory offers to settle them that students should reject
This article is more than 2 years old

Every year, hundreds of university students whose degrees, wellbeing, or future have been damaged by the mistakes of their university are unjustly deprived of rightful compensation.
Even when universities admit fault, they either offer no compensation or a sum that falls well short of what it should be.
Students should be wary of accepting the first offer made by the university. The problem is that students and SU advisers are often unaware of how to assess compensation.
In one case, the university offered £1,000 before eventually agreeing to pay £45,000. In another, the university offered £3,000 before agreeing to pay £85,000.
Elisabeth (not her actual name) was a disabled medical student who required an ergonomic chair during exams. She would otherwise suffer from painful spasms in her back. The university agreed to provide her with such a chair for each exam.
In one of the exams, the university failed to do so. The chair was mistakenly taken to the wrong exam hall. Elisabeth sat the 3-hour exam in considerable discomfort and failed by the narrowest of margins. As a result, she was withdrawn from her medical degree.
Using the university’s procedure, Elisabeth appealed the decision twice, without success.
The university said it was Elisabeth’s fault for not raising the issue of the missing chair during the exam.
With the university refusing to acknowledge fault, Elizabeth complained to the Office of the Independent Adjudicator (OIA), the ombudsman service for higher education. The OIA upheld her complaint, noting that the university had failed to meet its obligation to provide an ergonomic chair and that its decision to reject her appeals was unreasonable. The OIA invited the university to reconsider the case.
The university did so and agreed to reinstate Elisabeth and allow her to progress to the next year of study. By then, two years had elapsed since the failed exam. The university offered her £1,000 in compensation.
Despite her aching back, Elisabeth only just failed the exam. It was the only exam she had failed. An ergonomics expert wrote a report explaining the benefits of the chair and how an ordinary chair would likely affect someone suffering from Elisabeth’s back condition.
There was strong evidence that, with the chair, she would have obtained the few extra marks and progressed to the next year of study. She would have started work as a doctor two years earlier than she did.
The dismissive way in which Elizabeth was treated by the university and the long delay in resolving the problem also caused her significant psychological harm.
Elisabeth claimed compensation for pain, suffering and loss of amenity, loss of earnings, legal fees, and the cost of a report from an ergonomics expert to comment on the impact of the chair on her academic performance.
The case was settled pre-litigation for £45,000, a far cry from the £1,000 university’s first offer.
Elisabeth’s case is not unique. There are likely many students who accept offers that do not come close to reflecting their actual loss.
The relationship between a student and the university is a contractual one. In contract law, the overarching principle is that damages should place students in the same position as if the contract had been properly performed. In other words, the law tries, so far as possible, to put students in the position they would have been in had the university’s error not occurred.
Central to this exercise is comparing what would have happened without the university’s errors with what has in fact happened. It is then possible to assess the difference between the two scenarios to establish fair compensation.
SU advisers, whose role is to advise students on the reasonableness or otherwise of a university’s offer, should adopt a cautious stance towards offers made by the institution and understand the correct way to calculate loss and damage. This will require either training or the assistance of lawyers skilled in that exercise.
The valuation of damages, especially future losses such as loss of earnings or earning capacity, and what lawyers call “PSLA” (for pain, suffering and loss of amenity), can be challenging even for experienced lawyers.
Ideally, universities should avoid errors that result in harm to students. If such errors do occur, universities should own up to them and resist the temptation to take advantage of the ignorance or financial hardship of students by making derisory offers.

Jim Dickinson | Comment | 22/11/26

Mandy Crawford-Lee | Comment | 22/11/26

Jim Dickinson | Comment | 20/11/26

Karen Stroobants | Comment | 20/11/26

Francesca Woodward | Comment | 20/11/26

Hugh Jones | Comment | 20/11/26