The University and College Union is at a low point right now, but the whole sector needs it back to full strength. David Kernohan reads the tea leaves.
This article is more than 3 years old

So that’s it then.
Just under 20,000 members (of about 68,000 in total – down a fair few from last time) managed to both vote in the most recent University and Colleges Union (UCU) industrial action ballot, and vote in favour of strike action.
However stringent and potentially unfair the 2016 Trade Unions Act rules on aggregated ballots may be, these were rules known to UCU leaders at the time. Having sailed through the same rules on the two previous occasions (for two ballots each time) the 50 per cent turnout requirement was neither an unexpected nor an insurmountable barrier. Knowing this, they chose an aggregated rather than individual ballot.
The largest on-campus union will now head into the 2024-25 New JNCHES pay round (likely to begin early next year) without the benefit of an existing mandate for action.
Elsewhere UCU is managing ongoing industrial action in further education, running a redundancy-plan focused boycott of the University of Brighton, and is gearing up for a new campaign on academic freedom that seems to primarily involve union members resigning from UKRI committee roles. It has made a case for having achieved success in the USS dispute, having recently witnessed agreement on a return to pre-2020 valuation contribution levels.
All this is on top of the aftermath of the lost national ballot, the slow disintegration (and arguably patchy impact outside of a few key providers) of the marking and assessment boycott (MAB), the public opprobrium resulting from the MAB and the high profile individual impact on students, the abortive “freshers week strikes“, the controversial pause in the spring strike action, concerns over access to the strike fund, a running scandal over the terms and conditions of some of UCU’s own staff members, and a general sense that that aspects of union democracy frayed visibly during the past year. Add in a declining membership (the usual aftermath of sustained industrial action) and you might be forgiven for thinking that a period of retrenchment and strategic reflection is on order.
But the election of a general secretary and other key central roles, planned for next spring, is also beginning to exercise the minds of members. Jo Grady will seek a second term of office, and will be challenged by former president Vicky Blake (independent of any organised UCU faction) and Saira Weiner (backed by the influential UCU Left). The centre-left Campaign for UCU Democracy has not announced a candidate, and it’s been a while since we heard from the UCU Agenda (another centre-left faction). It is likely that Grady will retain the approval of the mainstream left UCU Commons.
It’s not just members that are thinking about the election – employers and their representatives will also have a wary eye over the field of runners and riders. With so many recent pay rounds ending in dispute, the likelihood is that the next one will proceed in a similar fashion – but there is also a worldview in which New JNCHES is beginning to look a bit silly. With a couple of high profile large employers leaving the national negotiations (Nottingham Trent, Queen’s University Belfast) in recent times, the idea of local negotiations on pay – as a way to address local issues and build local relationships – is returning to prominence.
The big UCEA idea to address this is a sensible one – an independent review of university finances to put the national negotiations on a firmer footing by basing them on an agreed perspective of what might be affordable. The current UCU leadership have cautiously welcomed this move, as have numerous prominent observers, but we are still waiting for further details to be agreed.
This is important because Grady’s media appearances (and social media presence) during last academic year’s campaign were marred by a decision to rely on an aggregate surplus figure suggesting that university leaders as a whole were sitting on a haul of cash and refusing to use it to top up pay. This was unhelpful as it was entirely inaccurate – it inflated member expectations on potential pay movement to a level that the majority of providers would simply be unable to meet, and it gave the most anti-university government in living memory cover to claim (once again) that the sector was awash with funding.
While this may have bolstered support for industrial action in the short term, it was always going to end in disappointment. There is an alternate timeline in which the union worked with employers to lobby government for additional funding to cover a pay claim (or at the very least, rising Teacher’s Pension Scheme costs, where universities are the only participants not to see government compensation) during a period of high inflation – when unions and employers work together they do tend to use complementary strengths to get things done, as we saw in the USS dispute. For many, however, this would be a bridge too far.
It feels counterintuitive, but employers and their representatives would prefer a larger stronger union to a smaller weaker one. A lurch to the left would shrink membership, and would lead to a multitude of small perpetual strikes at individual providers that would be almost entirely intractable. For preference, those involved in pay negotiations would want a union leadership with a focused and facts-based approach – it is much more likely that specific asks will be addressed next year than for workers to enjoy a large pay rise (except if the sector unexpectedly gets a further injection of cash). Universities – and UCEA – get the case for better pay even if the money to cover it isn’t there, so there is a door worth pushing on in terms of non-pay benefits (for example sustained work on casualisation, pay gaps and equality, and working conditions) as a result.
Union leaders walk a fine line. Banking a small win for members will bring accusations of capitulation or betrayal, taking a pragmatic approach based on the financial position of employers will lead to claims that bosses interpretations are being uncritically accepted. This being a union with many academics as members, ideological purity will be a big sticking point. A leader drawing on a broad coalition of factions is more likely to be bolder in annoying the fringes, and thus more likely to get results that benefit members facing particularly unpleasant terms and conditions.
The case for improving pay and conditions in universities is inarguable. I spend a lot of my time speaking to representatives of professional services staff – again and again I hear that poor pay and painful working conditions are making it harder and harder to recruit the staff that run universities. Data specialists, in particular, are looking elsewhere following the ongoing seven-year shambles that is Data Futures. Staff in finance, estates, human resources, and marketing are beginning to see the attraction of better paid, similar, jobs elsewhere. Do not think for a second that providers – and sector representatives – do not get this.
The work that the trade union does is important and often invisible. The support and advice offered to staff who rub up against poorly designed institutional processes help keep good people in work. The checks and balances that strategic engagement by campus unions at provider level provide a means to ensure that leaders can never forget the human basis of the value of a university, and helps providers make better decisions. And nationally, university staff – who feel attacked by government rhetoric and undervalued by popular discourse – need a strong and respected voice to argue their corner.
Right now, UCU is at a low point – but anyone who cares about universities wants to see it rise again.

Jim Dickinson | Comment | 20/11/26

Karen Stroobants | Comment | 20/11/26

Francesca Woodward | Comment | 20/11/26

Hugh Jones | Comment | 20/11/26