Is the UK’s external examiner system fit for purpose? As a new review is launched to make improvements, Jim Dickinson wonders if he’s seen it all before.
This article is more than 5 years old

Ever since universities minister Michelle Donelan started telling students that they could apply for tuition fee refunds if the “quality isn’t there”, students have been rightly asking “well what do you mean by quality”?
Many have therefore been surprised to learn that the judgement made of the academic “quality” of their programme is not something they are legally entitled to challenge or complain about. Academics own that.
Until the pandemic, it’s been a painful realisation that has usually kicked in when students have submitted an academic appeal. Partly because they don’t know what the standards are that universities are maintaining, and partly because students aren’t keen to complain about the people about to mark them, few students complain about poor “quality” teaching or support ahead of assessment – and if that then leads to them failing academically, they then angrily discover that they can’t challenge their marks on that basis because that’s “academic judgement”.
The magical power of academic judgement is theoretically established on the basis that it’s not just one academic making the decisions – some peer review is involved internally, and academics from other providers appear at exam boards externally to moderate the marking (usually notably without moderating the assessment design), and maybe to also chip some views in about the course more generally.
But as concerns have grown about “quality and standards” in a context of significant and rapid expansion and grade inflation, how “fit for purpose” are these processes of peer review?
I raise all of this because news reaches us that Universities UK (UUK) and GuildHE have asked the Quality Assurance Agency (QAA) to work with them to support universities to review and improve external examining practices.
They say that their recent progress review of efforts to tackle grade inflation demonstrates that universities are already taking steps to review how they use external examiners – but “inconsistencies remain” that they say “could undermine confidence in degree classifications”.
You can say that again. The UK’s external examiner system might have been described in 2003 as a “guardian of the reputation of UK higher education” by the old DfES, but it came in for stinging criticism by the Innovation, Universities, Science and Skills Committee in 2009. It argued that:
It concluded that:
The problems identified in the report eleven years ago feel contemporary and yet also exacerbated by a decade of expansion. The recommendations remain largely undelivered.
In 2010, Universities UK responded to the IUS Committee report by announcing a review of external examining. It said that it would:
Unsurprisingly, that Finch review found that external examining arrangements in the UK were working well generally (they always do), but the report offered recommendations for “increasing the degree of consistency” across institutions and “improving levels of transparency”, and strongly advised the adoption of its recommendations by universities as soon as possible. These included:
Not everyone was thrilled with this set of proposals. Peter Williams, by then a former head of the Quality Assurance Agency, said the plans represented at least the fourth attempt at reform in 40 years, but that “not a lot has happened previously”, and the report left “several elephants in the room”.
“There is no mention of the very considerable resources needed to implement the changes, no mention of the competing demands of research on academics’ time and no real attempt to get to grips with comparability,” Williams said.
On the idea that the system ensured a First was at the same standard as a First from anywhere else, he said “the term ‘broad comparability’ is pretty weaselly. How broad is broad?”
And he added that while the document was “much more realistic” about the limitations of the “still vitally important” role of externals, he said that without better pay, their only motivation was a sense of obligation. “This won’t be sustainable if the workload increases substantially – it’s already very shaky,” he warned.
The problems identified in that report still feel contemporary and exacerbated by expansion. And workload did increase, substantially. Yet many of the recommendations still remain undelivered.
By 2015, a Higher Education Funding Council for England (HEFCE) that was becoming increasingly interested in “quality” commissioned the then Higher Education Academy (HEA) to conduct a(nother) review of external examining arrangements in the UK to consider how the recommendations of the Finch Review had been implemented, to assess if the arrangements for external examining were fit for purpose, and to look ahead to the “changing higher education environment of 2025” (moocs, hoverboards, etc).
It concluded that there were a number of issues that needed to be addressed in order to establish external examiners as “key contributors” to the assurance of academic standards and to offer “confidence” in those standards to stakeholders. These issues were (and you’ll see a pattern forming here):
That review found that “empirical research provided clear evidence of the inconsistency and unreliability of higher education assessors”. Academics “have little knowledge of the difficulties and complexities of reliable marking”, and “they … lack experience of providers across the sector”, “receive limited support for the task from their own institutions”, and 10% had experienced pressure “not to rock the boat”.
On that basis, it recommended that the sector:
The problems identified in that report still feel contemporary and have all been further exacerbated by expansion. And yet still, many of the recommendations remain undelivered.
These days the Office for Students (OfS) has managed to run an entire review on quality and standards without so much as even mentioning the external examining system – and doesn’t seem especially interested in the comparatively low score that its own NSS generates every year on “marking and assessment has been fair”.
Nevertheless, it is proposing that while academics might contribute to some of its thoughts, at the core some qualitative judgements on quality will be made by its staff, and some quantitative judgements will be made by a comparison of metrics to absolute baselines (and by comparison to benchmarked outcomes in the TEF).
In other words, when it comes to making judgements about quality, the English regulator has decided that the judgement of academics – expressed partly through the external examiner system – are no longer sacrosanct. So why do university complaints processes and the courts still assume that they are when students are trying to complain?
In principle, back in 2010, sector legal expert David Palfreyman described immunity from adjudicatory or judicial scrutiny on the basis of academic judgment as the UK higher education system’s “get out of jail free card”.
He noted that similar deference to expertise in other sectors had rightly disappeared – particularly where service users had been able demonstrate that the supplier of a service has failed in their contractual duty to perform a promised service with reasonable skill and care. That’s an inconsistency that remains.
But if we’re going to avoid thousands of opportunistic appeals (as we’re about to see over Level 3 teacher-assessed grades in Examnishambles 2) it remains important that we try to make this work. Academics need the support, time and resource to assess with reasonable care and attention, internal moderation needs to be brought up to scratch, and external examining needs both to work and be seen to be working, consistently and with a focus on consistency.
But when many academics argue that the workload model they operate under prevents them from doing the initial marking with the requisite reasonable care and skill, you’d have to assume a powerful cultural incentive for both internal and external moderators to not rock those boats and cause the initial markers to get it in the neck.
Maybe it will be different this time. Universities UK and Guild HE have announced that they are working (again) with the QAA (again) to review the external examining system, with a view to considering (again):
This really ought to be the last chance saloon for the sector to get this creaking system’s house in order. Dismissing complaints on the basis of higher education staff’s magical capacity for academic judgment maintains the sector’s outward stance of “we know best” – all while it simultaneously repeatedly admits in reports, initiatives, and pilots that actually, we still don’t know best at all.
That the regulator has now rejected the magical powers as a mere conjuring trick is worrying. That lawyers, surgeons, plumbers and social workers long ago lost this flimsy defence, but the academy retains it in the plain sight of repeatedly unaddressed and systemic failure, is astonishing. That we’re fifty years on from the first time someone tried to fix this in higher education is unsurprising – but given how proud we all are of the rapidity and scale of change in HE just lately, it would be nice if we could deal with this one in the slipstream.

Jim Dickinson | Comment | 22/11/26

Mandy Crawford-Lee | Comment | 22/11/26

Jim Dickinson | Comment | 20/11/26

Karen Stroobants | Comment | 20/11/26

Francesca Woodward | Comment | 20/11/26

Hugh Jones | Comment | 20/11/26