David Kernohan is back with more data and analysis from the 2018 End of Cycle UCAS release – this time looking at differences in offer rates by demographic group, and overall offer-making behaviour.
This article is more than 7 years old

There’s three steps to the UCAS Cycle – an application, an offer, and the acceptance of that offer.
In the most part, UCAS mediates every part of this dance between the eager prospective student and the accommodating provider of their dreams. But to see the process as a series of transactions is an unwelcome simplification – strategy plays a part on each side. Here I’m going to take a look at the raw numbers of applications, offers, and acceptances for UK domiciled entrants in order to foreground the ways that provider-side stratagems interact with demand.
So here’s three data points and two synthetic measures, with caveats
This visualisation shows offer rate and acceptance rate at the top – sorted by offer rate. Raw application, offer, and acceptance numbers are at the bottom. Clicking on a data point will show data for that institution in a more readable form, and you can mouse over to see the figures. I’ve offered the usual filters to allow you to examine data by provider group and provider region. – you can also manually choose to look at a particular provider, or highlight a provider on the main graph. I’ve used data for 18 year old entrants so as to be consistent across both visualisations.
The offer rate statistic I calculated above is just a straight percentage, but UCAS has also developed a more sophisticated measure that takes into account demographic expectations. By doing this, we are able to look at the difference between an expected offer rate and an actual offer rate for different demographic groups – POLAR4, SIMD (for Scotland), Ethnicity, and Sex – for 18 year old entrants.
There are a complex set of considerations as to understanding the significance of these differences – UCAS have provided a lookup table to allow us to see whether a difference for a particular group at a particular provider is something we should be concerned about, or just background statistical noise.
This visualisation used colour to indicate whether a difference is significant based on the UCAS table. You can use the tabs to choose whether to examine POLAR4, Ethnicity, SIMD, or Sex. Choose an institution of interest via the drop downs on the right. You’re looking at data from 2018 – although a time series is available for those who are keen to examine these trends further.
It’s not been made easy to look at the significance of differences in offer rate for different demographic group. The look-up table is published only as a PDF, meaning that this information is very difficult to combine with the offer rate data at scale. I’m not sure why this is the case – it’s not trivial but far from impossible to match each institution and group based on the average offer rate. You can do it using the SUMIFS function in Excel if you are so minded. I recall working with David Morris to do this last year – and to save other wonks this hassle the data for 2018 is available to download from Tableau.
Not including a measure of significance alongside data is far from good practice – I’d hope that in future years UCAS makes this data available to everyone. It is time for the sector to explain evidence of significant bias in offer-making – clear presentation of the available data is essential in order for this to happen.

David Kernohan | Data | 21/11/26

David Kernohan | Data | 9/11/26

David Kernohan | Data | 6/11/26

David Kernohan | Data | 16/09/26

David Kernohan | Data | 18/08/26

David Kernohan | Data | 13/08/26