The purpose of this article is to collect together the most commonly cited examples of “no platform” in action at UK universities. This is to help people with an interest in the topic take an evidence-based perspective on the scope and nature of the issue.
What we can’t cover are instances where a decision has been made not to invite someone to speak at a campus event. Decisions on who should and shouldn’t be invited are made for a variety of reasons, including personal availability, previous contact, and level of potential interest. There’s no way of getting that kind of information about campus events.
No platform, in the UK, has a precise definition and an interesting history. Briefly, NUS has a policy position not to invite speakers from six organisations [pdf] to speak at events. These are included in the no platform policy as “individuals or members of organisations or groups identified by the Democratic Procedures Committee as holding racist or fascist views.”
A person who is “no platformed”, for the purposes of this list, is someone who has been denied the right to speak at an event run by a university or student society as a result of an active decision made to exclude them by a university or students’ union. Speakers that attract protest are not included – as protest is an example of the exercise of free speech.
Most recently, Jacob Rees-Mogg (MP for North East Somerset) was invited to speak at an event run by the UWE Politics and International Relations student society, held on UWE’s Frenchay campus in February 2017. He spoke at the event, though there was some disruption caused by protestors, none of whom are currently understood to be students. Rees-Mogg said that the incident should not be taken “out of proportion”, adding that verbal protest and heckling was “perfectly legitimate” and a part of political life.
Controversy reigned as it was claimed Nick Lowles (from the Hope not Hate campaign) had not been invited to speak at a national event in 2016 run by NUS Black Students due to alleged Islamophobia. Both the NUS president (Megan Dunn) and the leader of NUS Black Students (Malia Bouattia) denied that Lowles was on a “no platform” list – Dunn expressed a willingness to share a platform with Lowles or Hope not Hate, and Bouattia suggested that a decision had been made not to invite Lowles to speak at a particular event but denied it was a decision to “no platform” him.
The Edinburgh SU VP (Academic) was speaking during a large SU meeting in 2016. A complaint was made by an audience member concerning her hand motions and head-shaking during contributions from other speakers – in violation of a “safe space” policy. The complaint was discussed and overruled. The meeting continued.
A 2015 event at the University of Warwick, run by the Warwick Atheists, Secularists and Humanists student society, was to have featured Maryam Namazie (equality campaigner and member of the Council of Ex-Muslims of Britain). Warwick SU didn’t approve the invite initially, but the decision was overturned and the event went forward as planned.
In the veteran human rights campaigner’s own words: “Although I was not no-platformed, an NUS official refused to speak at a student meeting if I was on the platform. She claimed, without evidence, that I was racist and transphobic”. This was not NUS policy, and was a decision made by the individual in question. The event went ahead as planned, with Tatchell speaking.
The former leader of the British National Party has spoken, despite protests, at the University of Oxford. He was invited to speak at the Universities of Cambridge, St Andrews and Bath – each of these events were cancelled due to security fears. As an aside, an April Fool’s Day prank suggesting that Cambridge had rescinded his degree was reported by the Sun.
Julie Bindel and Milo Yiannopoulos
Both Bindel (feminist and Guardian writer) and Yiannopoulos (former Breitbart editor and Telegraph technology correspondent) were denied a platform at an event to be held at the University of Manchester in 2015. Bindel responded to criticisms centring on her alleged transphobia. Yiannopoulos subsequently spoke at an event at the University of Bristol, in a debate with Rebecca Reid.
Andrew Brons and Chris Beverley
Respectively a BNP MEP and Councillor, both were initially invited to speak at an event at Durham Union Society in 2010. Officers of the NUS at the time put pressure on the society to cancel the event, and were themselves condemned by the then NUS president, Wes Streeting. A final decision was made by DUS to cancel the event, citing security concerns. Durham SU subsequently voted to disaffiliate from NUS, though they later voted to reaffiliate.
The WikiLeaks founder was invited to speak at the Cambridge Union in 2015. There were protests, including the resignation of a women’s officer in protest over the sexual assault allegations against Assange. The event went ahead.