This article is more than 8 years old

It’s time to stop conflating the Russell Group with the ‘best’

We introduce a new Friday segment... Ant rants! Our own Ant Bagshaw takes issue with those wonks who use the Russell Group as a proxy for selective or elite universities.
This article is more than 8 years old

Ant Bagshaw is a Senior Advisor in L.E.K. Consulting’s Global Education Practice and co-editor, with Debbie McVitty, of Influencing Higher Education Policy

For all its insight (geddit?), I wasn’t too pleased when I saw the recent report from the Behavioural Insights Team (BIT) into their latest nudge. The one that encourages students to apply to selective universities.

I’m not upset because the intervention works; I’m not against encouraging school pupils to aim for universities with the highest entry tariffs. I am, however, disappointed that rather than use actual measures of selectivity in admissions, the report uses membership of the Russell Group as the proxy for selectivity.

This is hardly the first time that this mistake has been made. The Department for Education continues to procure and publish work which makes this error. When it comes to school data reporting, it uses Russell Group as a marker of performance in its official statistics. But those wonks working in education policy – in DfE and elsewhere – should know better. Why do we accept the persistent, but unverified, claim that Russell Group membership is synonymous with ‘best’?

There are, of course, other measures of selectivity. Ones which don’t rely on membership of a secretive and exclusive club. When it comes to official measures, we could use data from UCAS which can give specific, verifiable and flexible (i.e. responsive to any year-to-year changes) data on which universities actually take the students with the highest grades.

This might sound like I’m being harsh to BIT. While DfE needs to take the blame for publishing such research, we should also question the project’s design. The report acknowledges that “… the Russell Group is not a perfect proxy for selective universities (there are many selective universities outside the grouping).” But it then goes on to say “… given that the letters did not mention the Russell Group specifically, it seems a good proxy for aiming at more selective institutions.” Given that the study used UCAS data to see where students applied, why didn’t it use a better measure for selectivity?

I realise that the term Russell Group has common currency, and is used casually to refer to ‘elite’ universities. I get that most people can’t name all twenty-four member institutions off the top of their heads. But if you know – and surely BIT and DfE know – that the group is self-selecting, and self-serving (it’s a mission group, why would it not exist to serve its members?), how can you reasonably use it as a proxy selectivity?

This debate has been rumbling on for years, and it’s time that we stopped accepting the lazy use of ‘mission group equals X’. If you’re not going to take my word that the grouping is arbitrary, there’s Vikki Boliver’s 2015 paper to read.

And as an aside, if you thought that the situation we’re in is a result of the work of the group itself, perhaps reconsider. There’s more scrutiny applied to its members as a result of membership, for example (and not unreasonably) on measures of access and widening participation. But selective universities outside the Russell Group arguably get less scrutiny. This is all the more reason that we should use the actual data on selectivity of institutions, and use it to increase the quality of the higher education debate.

40 Comments
Oldest
Newest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Vicky Gunn
8 years ago

tag:twitter.com,2013:885757555829465090_favorited_by_270791158

Vicky Gunn

https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/885757555829465090#favorited-by-270791158

James Bruce
8 years ago

tag:twitter.com,2013:885757555829465090_favorited_by_304487067

James Bruce

https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/885757555829465090#favorited-by-304487067

Alfred Thumser
8 years ago

tag:twitter.com,2013:885757555829465090_favorited_by_570596357

Alfred Thumser

https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/885757555829465090#favorited-by-570596357

Tom Levinson
8 years ago

tag:twitter.com,2013:886855531264192515_favorited_by_398042077

Tom Levinson

https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/886855531264192515#favorited-by-398042077

Enzo
8 years ago

It’s time to stop conflating the Russell Group with the ‘best’ wonkhedev.jynk.net/blogs/its-time… via @wonkhe

Doctoral School
8 years ago

tag:twitter.com,2013:886855531264192515_favorited_by_3524318957

Doctoral School

https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/886855531264192515#favorited-by-3524318957

Harriet
8 years ago

It’s time to stop conflating the Russell Group with the ‘best’ wonkhedev.jynk.net/blogs/its-time… via @wonkhe < well said Ant, on my list of rants too!

LCC municipal
8 years ago

tag:twitter.com,2013:885757555829465090_favorited_by_781411003997233152

LCC municipal

https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/885757555829465090#favorited-by-781411003997233152

Noelle Rum
8 years ago

tag:twitter.com,2013:886855531264192515_favorited_by_253243871

Noelle Rum

https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/886855531264192515#favorited-by-253243871

'Monte' Sam Harding
8 years ago

tag:twitter.com,2013:885757555829465090_favorited_by_272970670

‘Monte’ Sam Harding

https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/885757555829465090#favorited-by-272970670

Andrew Stronach
8 years ago

tag:twitter.com,2013:885757555829465090_favorited_by_322163978

Andrew Stronach

https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/885757555829465090#favorited-by-322163978

Rachel
8 years ago

tag:twitter.com,2013:886855531264192515_favorited_by_130922243

Rachel

https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/886855531264192515#favorited-by-130922243

Liz Oakley-Brown
8 years ago

?

LTD @ Edge Hill
8 years ago

tag:twitter.com,2013:886855531264192515_favorited_by_169931537

LTD @ Edge Hill

https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/886855531264192515#favorited-by-169931537

YoDa™
8 years ago

tag:twitter.com,2013:885757555829465090_favorited_by_749173764689162240

YoDa™

https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/885757555829465090#favorited-by-749173764689162240

claire walsh
8 years ago

tag:twitter.com,2013:885757555829465090_favorited_by_167353977

claire walsh

https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/885757555829465090#favorited-by-167353977

Deborah Fish
8 years ago

tag:twitter.com,2013:885757555829465090_favorited_by_2414439619

Deborah Fish

https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/885757555829465090#favorited-by-2414439619

Simon Thompson
8 years ago

tag:twitter.com,2013:886855531264192515_favorited_by_843467107

Simon Thompson

https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/886855531264192515#favorited-by-843467107

Magnus L. Johnson
8 years ago

tag:twitter.com,2013:886855531264192515_favorited_by_141941487

Magnus L. Johnson

https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/886855531264192515#favorited-by-141941487

Noelle Rum
8 years ago

tag:twitter.com,2013:885757555829465090_favorited_by_253243871

Noelle Rum

https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/885757555829465090#favorited-by-253243871

Susan Stewart
8 years ago

tag:twitter.com,2013:886855531264192515_favorited_by_145233891

Susan Stewart

https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/886855531264192515#favorited-by-145233891

Sue Sherman
8 years ago

tag:twitter.com,2013:885757555829465090_favorited_by_40226398

Sue Sherman

https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/885757555829465090#favorited-by-40226398

HESPA
8 years ago

tag:twitter.com,2013:886855531264192515_favorited_by_2296205383

HESPA

https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/886855531264192515#favorited-by-2296205383

Helen Hampson
8 years ago

tag:twitter.com,2013:885757555829465090_favorited_by_2333754337

Helen Hampson

https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/885757555829465090#favorited-by-2333754337

Charlotte Malton
8 years ago

tag:twitter.com,2013:886855531264192515_favorited_by_3629980642

Charlotte Malton

https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/886855531264192515#favorited-by-3629980642

Anil K Jain, FRCR
8 years ago

tag:twitter.com,2013:886855531264192515_favorited_by_28668849

Anil K Jain, FRCR

https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/886855531264192515#favorited-by-28668849

#23
8 years ago

tag:twitter.com,2013:885757555829465090_favorited_by_433977280

#23

https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/885757555829465090#favorited-by-433977280

Charlie Hughes
8 years ago

tag:twitter.com,2013:886855531264192515_favorited_by_298609825

Charlie Hughes

https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/886855531264192515#favorited-by-298609825

John Baker
8 years ago

Loving the ‘AntRants’ strapline. We need more indignant personalisation online! Brightest is simply code for privilege & we need to open up.

RMarggrafTurley
8 years ago

tag:twitter.com,2013:885757555829465090_favorited_by_424237010

RMarggrafTurley

https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/885757555829465090#favorited-by-424237010

Republic of Open
8 years ago

It’s time to stop conflating the Russell Group with the ‘best’ ow.ly/f4SC30dG7RT

Liz Bennett
8 years ago

It’s time to stop conflating the Russell Group with the ‘best’ ow.ly/f4SC30dG7RT

Helen Louise Young
8 years ago

tag:twitter.com,2013:885757555829465090_favorited_by_2851065387

Helen Louise Young

https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/885757555829465090#favorited-by-2851065387

matthew rubino
8 years ago

It’s time to stop conflating the Russell Group with the ‘best’ ow.ly/f4SC30dG7RT

Chris Husbands
8 years ago

tag:twitter.com,2013:886855531264192515_favorited_by_325116618

Chris Husbands

https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/886855531264192515#favorited-by-325116618

Gin Bhandal
8 years ago

It’s time to stop conflating the Russell Group with the ‘best’ ow.ly/f4SC30dG7RT

Gin Bhandal
8 years ago

tag:twitter.com,2013:886855531264192515_favorited_by_1209282776

Gin Bhandal

https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/886855531264192515#favorited-by-1209282776

Frank Rennie
8 years ago

tag:twitter.com,2013:886855531264192515_favorited_by_560552115

Frank Rennie

https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/886855531264192515#favorited-by-560552115

Ian McNay
8 years ago

Thanks you for this. I have been arguing a similar case for some time based on a variety of excellences. But, as Howard Newby has said, the English [and he was specific] have a genius for turning diversity into hierarchy. Fitness for purpose as a criterion has to recognise a diversity of purposes, and for most undergraduate applicants, who now pay most of most universities’ income, that gives teaching and support to learning priority over research [maybe that is why Chris Husbands gives this a thumbs up]: their value for money ratings have been going down in the years since… Read more »

Mike Grey
8 years ago

As the focus shifts to learning gain and benchmarked metrics, we can’t use mission groups as proxies for quality! wonkhedev.jynk.net/blogs/its-time…