Alan Milburn’s report would reduce apprenticeship opportunities for those aged 25 and up. Mandy Crawford-Lee pushes back

Alan Milburn has delivered. From a Welfare State to a Working State is the most serious attempt in a generation to confront a youth participation crisis that has left a million young people outside of learning, a job or training.
In May, the University Vocational Awards Council (UVAC) called the interim report a powerful diagnosis. This final report is a bold prescription. The report and the media response to it has led to a number of memorable slogans and soundbites including “work beats welfare”, “earn or learn”, “cheque-and-forget”, “NEET Zero” and “give and get”, all intended to frame the UK response to youth welfare reform, apprenticeships and skills not just for the remainder of this Parliament but for the next decade.
Starting with the good news, Milburn wants the apprenticeship budget to match the full value of levy receipts, ending a Treasury top slice estimated to be worth around £1bn in 2027–28. For as long as the levy has existed, UVAC has long argued that every pound employers pay into the levy should be spent on apprenticeships and skills. Milburn now says the same – but his recommendations could have gone further by recommending to government that 16-18-year-old apprentices should be funded from the 16-19 DfE budget. The real risk is that the levy becomes a youth and entry-level mechanism alone, at the expense of higher-level skills.
We also welcome the ambition: doubling the number of young people achieving an apprenticeship, lifting under-25 starts, and making apprenticeships the review’s largest education and skills priority. Universities want more young people on apprenticeships, at every level of skill. Degree apprenticeships are a youth route: about 30 per cent of chartered manager degree apprentices are aged 24 or under. The choice between young people and higher levels remains a false one. The call for more provision at levels 4 and 5 and clearer progression from further to higher education is equally welcome. Milburn also says plainly that higher-level routes should not be closed to achieve his goals.
Universities are essential to making this progression a reality. Working alongside further education providers and employers, they create pathways into higher technical and degree-level qualifications. These routes also widen access to professional careers for people who may not have previously considered, or had the opportunity to pursue, a university route.
Now the problem. The review proposes cutting government funding for apprentices aged 25 and over by a quarter, and asks ministers to be ready to reduce this to a half by 2031–32. Employers would pay the difference in cash. The report itself concedes that institutions whose provision is weighted towards adult and higher-level apprenticeships would lose funding.
Let’s be clear about who the adult apprentice is. They are the healthcare assistant who left school at 16 and is now training as a registered nurse. They are the police constable, the social worker, and the engineering technician who never had the chance to progress to be the professional they work alongside. Making their training more expensive for the employer does not create a single level 2 vacancy for a 17-year-old. Instead, it shuts someone else out of the professions and closes pathways to higher paid careers.
Milburn’s own caveat, that the cuts be phased around regulated and priority occupations including health and adult social care, clearly acknowledges this risk. The NHS, policing and social care grow their own workforces through degree apprenticeships, often in places where graduate recruitment fails. But priority occupations go far beyond health: think engineering, digital, construction, and the defence and clean energy roles which the Industrial Strategy depends on. Draft the carve-out narrowly and it will hurt the very sectors government is counting on for growth. It will also undermine the university-employer partnerships and specialist provision needed to develop these workforces.
The real lesson of the review is that the problem is money, not allocation, when the government is trying to address an economic, fiscal, social and moral challenge. Milburn himself found that only £1 in every £25 spent on youth benefits goes on helping young people into work or learning. That is where the rebalancing should come from. Asking a fixed apprenticeship budget to pay for a national youth guarantee and the country’s higher-level skills needs is a zero-sum game.
At UVAC we’re now making a simple request of government, as it weighs Milburn alongside the forthcoming Timms review. Accept the end of the top slice. Back the youth ambition with new money, not cuts to investment in adult and higher skills. Publish the impact evidence on level 7 before any further restriction. Build a funded progression ladder from pre-apprenticeship through level 3 to higher and degree apprenticeships, with a guaranteed next step for every young person who completes.
And finally, give universities a seat at the table as the new funding model is designed, recognising their contribution to higher-level technical and professional skills.
Milburn rightly called for a system reset. A reset that pits a 19-year-old against a 35-year-old trainee nurse is no reset at all. The choice is not and should never be between young people and higher-level skills.

Jim Dickinson | Comment | 20/11/26

Karen Stroobants | Comment | 20/11/26

Francesca Woodward | Comment | 20/11/26

Hugh Jones | Comment | 20/11/26