Louise Drumm, Kerith George-Briant, and Rosemarie McIlwhan outline how Scottish educators’ principles on AI have been adopted across the whole sector

In the noise and fury of attention-grabbing headlines about AI which are more or less repackaging well-worn truisms, it’s easy to miss the quieter voices pointing out less exciting terms like values, equity, and collaboration.
From 2023 onwards, organisations and groups began publishing guidance – including the Russell Group with its Principles on the use of Generative AI tools in education. However, for a group of those leading on AI in Scottish universities, we were seeking to fully reflect our history of enhancement-led, equity-based, open and collaborative education and to capture the widest possible thinking on the subject. So, the Scottish AI in Tertiary Education Network (ScAITEN) set about drafting a set of principles to meet the need to centre human-based education, while also acknowledging the messy reality of what that may look like.
ScAITEN is a community of practice established in 2023 as a response to developments in AI and related challenges we are facing in education. ScAITEN comprises representation from all Scottish institutions and many colleges where members have an institutional role in leading on AI. The network is committed to open education, collaboration, and education for the common good, with an ethos of creating an open and safe space for sharing, collaboration, engagement, and professional development.
After an extensive consultative process with its members, ScAITEN released its statement of principles on the use of generative artificial intelligence in learning and teaching with a Creative Commons licence in 2025. The work was informed by concurrent research projects which explored staff and students’ attitudes towards AI tools. The ScAITEN research found a wide variety of experiences, including some, but not widespread, deliberate misuse by students, and striking evidence of increasing polarisation, as outlined by Michael Webb’s comparison piece.
In the face of alarming narratives in the media about students cheating and lived experience of increasing academic workloads related to academic integrity, holding true to the values of trust and the importance of the relationality of education became more important than ever for those of us in the network.
The principles proved to be prescient on a number of counts, not least the growing concerns of environmental impact of AI tools or the negative effects on wellbeing. Increasingly, calls came from students and academics for greater clarity; survey after survey reported findings that everyone just wanted to know where the line in the sand was drawn.
The equivocations of many different institutional guidance and policy documents across the sector, present in the ubiquitous phrase “challenges and opportunities”, demonstrated a vagueness in responsibilities and promised false simplicity. This is a complex, wicked problem, and to pretend otherwise does not recognise the issues being managed by those who study and work in universities. Through the growing interest in these principles, it became clear that they were meeting a need in setting the tone and shared understandings from which institutions could start to have more nuanced discussions where academic agency and empowerment were the starting point, rather than issuing top-down directives.
While the principles were being gradually adopted and adapted across institutions, Universities Scotland’s Learning and Teaching Committee formally endorsed them for the whole sector. Furthermore, it recommended they were also discussed at Universities Scotland Main Committee, where it was decided to adopt a version which covered all areas of activity by Scottish Universities, not just learning and teaching. Here is the beauty of a Creative Commons licence: adaptation to extend to a wider, or narrower, context is actively encouraged. It is these Principles for the Scottish Sector which have recently launched.
The principles centre on 10 core values to guide the use of AI, namely: human-centred, agency, trust, ethical, equitable, environmentally responsible, collaboration, openness, transparency, and safety.
None of these are in themselves novel to the area, but collectively they have provided a nuanced and informed basis from which universities have begun to create their own guidance and policies. Not only that, but interest from further afield has resulted in their reuse, for example, in Canada where the British Columbia Ministry of Post-Secondary Education and Future Skills adapted them into their post-secondary digital learning strategy. Closer to home, the sector principles enabled institutions to align policies and guidance, with the reassurance that all were singing from the same hymn sheet. At Abertay University, a new AI Governance Framework was developed to cover the development, procurement and use of AI.
Addressing questions about AI across all areas of university activity is challenging and can touch on emotive issues like identity and professional values. Establishing trust and transparency for those discussions requires honesty in admitting that there are no simple answers. In the end, the proof will not be whether such principles can set the world alight with excitement, but whether they can help change a decision to a better outcome. If these principles help us keep sight of issues of equity, transparency, and safety, then better decisions can be made on what universities buy, how we treat students, and collaborate with each other – it doesn’t sound quite so boring after all.
Mark Andrews | Comment | 17/11/26