Alice Wilson argues presentations can test performance more than understanding and makes the case for valuing quieter and more technical skills

Presenting an argument in front of an audience of 30 silent peer observers is part of almost all business degrees in the UK, but how many jobs actually require you to do it?
Very few. Perhaps, as lecturers, our minds have been addled by our own biases; we spend hundreds of hours each year getting up in front of a crowd to give presentations, so it must be valuable and important, right? I am sceptical.
Wherever people are gathered and organising together to get something done, business is taking place. Quiet decision making between small groups; one-on-one conversations; gently comforting a colleague in distress; excavating action items from a 52-page email exchange between distributed team members – this is all business activity. These examples all require communication skills, and I agree that supporting students to build their confidence in speaking, communicating, and expressing their views is a good, useful, important part of an HE offering.
However, the insistence that students must be able to get up in front of an audience and pitch an idea or justify an argument shows an ingrained view of business as a very specific type of highly corporate activity. And presenting to an audience represents only very specific kinds of roles within that corporate environment. It would be like music schools agreeing that students need to leave their degrees knowing how to keep time, so they embed piano competency in their core module assessments. Does piano help students learn to keep time? Yes, probably. Is it the only way to learn that skill? No. Does the focus on piano suggest a very narrow view of what musical ability in this regard means? I think so.
Consider a student who has undertaken a brilliant analysis of a company’s sustainability strategy, identifying its structural weaknesses and proposing thoughtful, evidence-based solutions. Now consider another student whose analysis is comparatively superficial, but who delivers it with the polish and confidence of a TED speaker. Which student has better demonstrated their understanding of sustainable business? Of course, this depends on what the assessment is intended to measure. But that is precisely the point; if our learning outcome is critical analysis, why should the ability to perform that analysis in front of an audience affect the student’s grade?
Presentations risk introducing an additional, potentially irrelevant competency into assessments of quite different abilities. We would not dream of assessing a student’s understanding of financial accounting by requiring them to demonstrate their findings through interpretive dance – though I would dearly love to see this. Why, then, is public presenting treated as such a good, normal, unproblematic vehicle for assessing almost anything? One of my main concerns here is that by privileging the performance of authority, we risk teaching students to look like leaders before we’ve taught them what brilliant leadership can actually mean. Not only that, but the type of leader this performance authority mimics is a very particular and limiting version of a leader; it’s a Wolf of Wall Street go-getter winning major corporate deals in the city type.
In a conversation with a peer I explained this view, to which he earnestly replied, “but business schools don’t want to churn out corporate drones.” This encapsulates the mistake perfectly: the idea that a student will graduate from a business school only to become either a corporate CEO who needs to present and pitch and sell, or a “drone”, as if there is no value, dignity, or contribution available in positions that are quieter, or more technical, or more introvert-coded.
I think there is a hidden curriculum at work here, too. That being said, I am a critical sociologist, so I always think there is a hidden curriculum at work everywhere.
But let me make my case so you can judge for yourself; I think when business schools repeatedly reward students for performing a particular type of businessperson – articulate, confident, assertive, comfortable commanding a room – we are telling them something about whose contributions we consider valuable. This image of a “successful” businessperson is gendered, ableist, and a host of other unhelpful things that truncate our collective view of great leaders. We know that universities are highly active in shaping our collective understanding of what work is, and what success within it looks like; that’s why (good) business schools spend so much time and energy on decolonising the curriculum, for example.
I think scrutinising the role of presenting in front of the class is actually part of decolonising the curriculum for exactly this reason; when you ask a class of first years to name great business leaders the names that usually come up are people like Jeff Bezos, Elon Musk, Mark Zuckerberg. White, cis, anglo-phonic, heterosexual men from the Global North. “Leaders” who take to the stage and pitch ideas and sell to big audiences and make a load of money. There is so much more to business success and leadership than these examples suggest. I think spending more time in the curriculum platforming, coaching, and rewarding skills outside of the present-pitch performance can only help to reinforce the idea that great business skills and great leadership come in more diverse forms.
Ironically, even within the highly corporate space of financial services, this normative model of public speaking doesn’t fit. I founded and ran my own startup in the financial services sector for three years. My own business activities included organising and directing a team of six, and nobody was required to do the kind of public speaking that universities seem so concerned with – nobody ever had to stand up in front of a group of 20 peers and speak for 15 minutes. We pitched and won large international clients, we secured suppliers, we undertook marketing and did a thousand thousand hours of networking; none of it required anything resembling the presentations that feature in so many HE assessments.
The view that this kind of pitch-oriented presenting is so vital to successful graduate outcomes that it cannot be omitted from university curricula is bizarrely popular, despite the real and tragic evidence we have of how badly wrong this type of pedagogical enforcement can go. If universities want to prepare students for a life of contribution and value, I think this must include visions of learners’ futures that exist outside of corporate pitching skills.

Louise Drumm | Comment | 19/11/26

Samantha Love | Comment | 18/11/26

Holly Parrott | Comment | 18/11/26

Mark Andrews | Comment | 17/11/26

Doug Specht | Comment | 17/11/26

Andy Mycock | Comment | 16/11/26