A Policy Exchange proposal to bring back number controls has a curiously old fashioned feel. David Kernohan assesses the damage
This article is more than 3 years old

The King’s Speech, scheduled for 7 November, marks the start of the final session of this parliament.
It’s the last chance for Rishi Sunak’s government to announce a full programme of legislation before the general election, expected in either May or October of 2024.
Coupled with the Autumn Statement (due 22 November), the focus is very unlikely to be the “long-term decisions for a brighter future” – expect a retail offer of very visible and ostensibly popular bills, backed by giveaways and short-term financial thinking.
The start of a parliamentary session also offers think-tanks and commentators the chance to submit their wishlists – Policy Exchange has been early off the mark with an optimistic collection of 13 bill proposals drafted by former Department for Education special advisor Iain Mansfield.
His proposed Higher Education and Skills Bill is ostensibly a rebalancing between higher and further education funding. What the proposal actually covers is the reimposition of student number controls, with the savings reinvested in incentives for employers to invest in skills.
Under Mansfield’s plans, the Secretary of State would annually (in the spring before each application cycle) set the total number of undergraduate university places the government would fund (which could not be lower than 95 per cent of the places funded in the previous year, and would be approved via a negative statutory instrument). The Office for Students would then set numbers caps on all registered higher education providers, with the total number of places available adding up to the government requested total.
It’s suggested that OfS could have regard to the following in setting these provider number caps:
But OfS would be specifically forbidden from having regard to
It would also not be able to set a provider limit lower than 95 per cent of the previous year, unless the provider asks for that. For providers that exceed the limit there would be a hefty fine (twice the the fee income for the excess students), but OfS could waive this if it is within two per cent of the cap if it thinks that the infringement was “neither negligent or intentional”, but only once during a three year period. There would be a fairly constrained right of appeal, and the Open University would be exempt from all limits on funded places.
It’s anticipated that the Secretary of State would use this mechanism to reduce student numbers – the savings would be used offer all UK business a corporation tax relief equal to 10 per cent of what they spend on skills (here drawn as apprenticeship wages, any course at a registered (HE, FE, independent) provider, T level placements, Skills Bootcamps, and the costs of external trainers. This wouldn’t apply for statutory training – so no health and safety training would be covered.
Just about everyone with an analysis of the problems facing higher education has contemplated the return of some form of student number controls in recent years. At this point it makes more sense to look at the nuances of each version rather than talk about the issue in general terms (something that there has been no shortage of on the pages of Wonkhe).
The Mansfield variant presupposes a mechanism to shrink spending on the sector (though the mechanism would also allow for controlled growth should a future government want to fund that). It presupposes a static unit of resource which would not be affected by inflation – indeed under these plans inflationary increases in fees or maintenance loans would be constrained by the need to specify a cap similar to the previous year’s intake.
The OfS would get a raft of new powers to determine how the overall reduction would be felt in the sector – the outline from Policy Exchange doesn’t suggest any means of prioritising these. Surprisingly, though national skills needs would be a factor it appears local skills needs would not, and the OfS would not be allowed to make determinations based on the subject area of provision anyway. If Policy Exchange was serious about using controls for higher-level skills planning, there would be a huge subject component here.
The inclusion of “provider wishes” in the list of things OfS could consider suggests some kind of a student numbers bidding process – a reverse additional student numbers bidding round, for older readers – that would see providers arguing to keep recruiting at current levels, rather than asking for expansion.
I really liked the availability of accommodation as a potential criteria (given the multiple stories of students forced to live many hours from “their” campus), though it’s fair to say that this presupposes a very traditional model of attendance. Any government that was thinking about local high-level skills needs would want to consider supporting growth in local or commuter students.
Which takes me to the absence of the lifelong learning entitlement as a consideration. LLE students would be accessing fee and maintenance loans at the same level (pro-rata), yet this sketch of a bill does nothing to limit anything other than traditional undergraduate recruitment. What would stop a provider that had been ordered to cut recruitment simply recruiting the same students, for the same amount of income, via the LLE?
There’s nothing specifically here about international recruitment either. The focus on fee loans does suggest the caps would only apply to home students, but we have seen that universities are very happy to recruit internationally. It would feel odd to have a world class higher education system that we are literally banning home students from attending – and doing nothing to address the underlying issue of funding – meaning that the whole thing is basically an incentive to recruit from overseas.
We have to judge this bill as a way to shrink the sector – the link to employer-funded skill provision is facile (why not expand the apprenticeship levy as a skills levy, given that it already exists?) and unlikely to do anything to materially address the issue that (uniquely in Europe) most employers have very little interest in offering training. The shrinkage, realistically, would need to be fairly evenly distributed across all providers (given the 95 per cent provider cap) and thus unlikely to be strategic in nature.
But in shrinking the sector based on institutions (rather than subjects) and national rather than local skills needs betrays a very old-fashioned perspective on what universities do and why. And even if this is an attempt to shift away from expensive three year undergraduate degree provision, it’s a difficult message to sell on the doorstep that your children will be less likely to attend university because the government don’t think they are worth it.

Jim Dickinson | Comment | 20/11/26

Karen Stroobants | Comment | 20/11/26

Francesca Woodward | Comment | 20/11/26

Hugh Jones | Comment | 20/11/26