For David Mather, student progression may not be a proxy for wellbeing

“Belonging” has become one of the most comfortable ideas in higher education.
It sits easily in strategies, frameworks and student experience plans. It is rarely challenged.
Students who feel they belong are more likely to stay, engage and succeed. That much is well established.
What is less examined is what belonging looks like in practice, who defines it and what happens to students who do not recognise themselves in it. At the same time, a large group of students remain unseen: the silent middle.
Those who form the silent middle are not failing, but nor are they thriving. They attend enough. They submit work that passes. They do not raise concerns and they do not seek support.
They do not appear in crisis. They do not appear in celebration. They simply pass through.
In systems built on alerts and thresholds, they are easy to miss. Progression becomes a proxy for wellbeing. Silence becomes a proxy for satisfaction. Both are unsafe assumptions.
Silence is often read as disengagement. It can be argued that it is more often a rational response.
For some students, silence reflects matters that are structural. Paid work, commuting and caring responsibilities limit how far they can engage beyond the minimum. For others, silence is cultural. The expectation to speak, perform and disclose is not universal. What we recognise as engagement is shaped by a narrow set of norms.
Then, in some instances, silence is strategic. If surface learning is enough to pass, then surface learning is what many will do. Students are not passive recipients of education. They read the system and respond to it. And, of course, silence can be protective. Choosing not to be visible can be a way of managing confidence, identity or uncertainty.
None of these silent responses are accidental. They are patterned behaviours within the conditions we create.
Belonging is rarely neutral. In practice, it is often translated into a familiar set of behaviours – including speaking in seminars, contributing to group work, engaging beyond the curriculum, disclosing difficulty, and being visible.
These are not unreasonable expectations. They are also not universal ones. They privilege a particular model of the student: available, confident and willing to perform engagement in recognisable ways. Those who do not fit that model are not necessarily disengaged. They are simply harder to see.
Much of the sector’s work on belonging is well intentioned. It aims to draw students in. However, it can also create new forms of exclusion.
Students from distinct cultural backgrounds may not prioritise verbal participation. Neurodivergent students may find socially intensive environments difficult. Those with external responsibilities may not have time to engage beyond what is required.
In these cases, belonging becomes something that must be demonstrated. If you cannot perform it, you risk being read as absent. The silent middle sit precisely in this gap. Not absent but not fully recognised.
If the silent middle exists in a way that many of us recognise, then some of our assumptions need to shift.
For example, progression is not enough. A student passing quietly through a course is not necessarily a student who is well supported or well connected. And participation needs to be broadened. If engagement is only recognised when it is visible, then many forms of learning remain invisible by design.
Support cannot rely on disclosure. Systems that depend on students asking for help will continue to miss those to whom have learned not. And surface learning is not a student deficit. It is often a rational response to assessment systems that allow it.
None of this requires abandoning belonging. It requires being more precise about what we mean by it.
Not all students want the same relationship with higher education. Some are with us to transform. Others are here to complete. Some will build identity and community. Others will move through quietly and successfully. The question is not whether these students belong. It is whether our definition of belonging is wide enough to include them.
Higher education increasingly operates as if all students can be seen through data, dashboards and metrics. The silent middle challenge that assumption.
They should remind us that what is not visible is not necessarily absent and what is not measured is not necessarily unimportant. If belonging is only recognised when it is visible, measurable and easy to evidence, then many students will never fully appear within it. That is not a failure of students. It is a limitation of how we have chosen to see them.

Mandy Crawford-Lee | Comment | 22/11/26

Jim Dickinson | Comment | 20/11/26

Karen Stroobants | Comment | 20/11/26

Francesca Woodward | Comment | 20/11/26

Hugh Jones | Comment | 20/11/26

Alice Wilson | Comment | 19/11/26