Doug Specht makes the case that university departments can be run down long before anyone votes to close them

The cuts across British higher education are no longer exceptional events.
Times Higher Education’s analysis of 118 Universities UK members found that 16,800 people received severance payments in 2024–25, with compensation for loss of office reaching £441.9 million. Behind those figures are colleagues, careers, and academic communities. Yet even this accounting cannot capture everything being dismantled. A department does not have to be formally closed to be made incapable of continuing.
There is another way to close it. Stop replacing selected staff. Freeze its budget while costs rise. Remove its authority to spend what remains. Reduce its marketing, delay decisions on new courses and withhold the professional support needed to develop partnerships or recruit students. Then ask why it is failing to grow. By the time closure reaches a committee, the decisions that made it appear inevitable may already be years old.
This is where the political argument begins. “Financial necessity” describes a constraint, but it does not explain who created it, whose work was sacrificed or which alternatives were refused. Presenting every cut as an unavoidable response to the balance sheet removes those questions from discussion. A choice about the future of education becomes an exercise in administering a supposedly predetermined outcome.
The crisis has political authors. In England, the undergraduate fee cap remained frozen from 2017 until the 2025–26 increase. Across the UK, restrictions introduced in January 2024 prevented most international students on taught courses from bringing dependants. The contradiction is that international recruitment is expected to sustain university finances while being treated politically as a problem to contain. Institutions are left to reconcile competing government priorities through their staffing budgets.
Nor is government merely setting the financial weather. During her tenure as education secretary, Bridget Phillipson instructed the Office for Students to reprioritise high-cost subject funding away from media studies, journalism, publishing, and information services. That was not a market delivering an impartial verdict on academic value. It was a ministerial choice about which subjects deserved additional public support. Invoking institutional autonomy does not make responsibility for such choices disappear. It allows the government to shape the options while universities announce the losses.
Institutional leaders nevertheless retain choices of their own. A national funding crisis does not make every local allocation fair, every reorganisation necessary or every neglected department a failure. The alternative to blaming individual vice chancellors for everything cannot be absolving them of anything. The relevant question is not simply whether savings are needed, but who gets to decide what survives, on what evidence and with what opportunity for challenge.
Consider voluntary severance. It can offer a genuine choice and a less damaging exit than compulsory redundancy. But “voluntary” describes the terms of departure, not the consequences for those remaining. If expertise disappears without replacement, courses narrow and workloads grow. The absence of compulsory redundancies is not evidence that academic capacity has been protected. Nor should the preferences of those accepting a package stand in for collective discussion about the department they leave behind.
Budget centralisation can produce a similar separation of power from responsibility. A department remains accountable for recruitment while losing control over the activity that might improve it. Its business case waits. Its website goes unchanged. Its proposed partnership needs support that never arrives. Each delay has an explanation; collectively, they can make development impossible. A unit denied the means to act is then judged for its failure to deliver.
Marketing makes the circularity particularly clear. Reduce a course’s visibility and recruitment may weaken. Use those numbers to justify further withdrawal and the institution risks manufacturing the evidence for its own decision. Demand is being treated as something discovered in the market, rather than something universities also help create. “Unviable” can become the name given to a course after the conditions of viability have been removed.
Course suspensions occupy this ambiguous territory, but the wider contraction is not confined to any one institution. A 2025 Universities UK survey of 60 institutions found that 49 per cent had closed courses and 55 per cent had consolidated them. These figures do not establish how individual decisions were made, but they underline the need to scrutinise changes to provision across the sector. A review need not lead to withdrawal. The question is what resources, timetable and criteria make a pause genuinely reversible, rather than closure stretched over several recruitment cycles?
None of this requires a secret masterplan. The accountability problem is precisely that cumulative damage can arise from decisions approved separately, without anyone defending their combined effect. A vacancy control here, a spending restriction there: each looks temporary or technical. Taken together, they can settle the future of a discipline before that future has been openly debated.
The sector-level consequences are political too. If subjects retreat into institutions or places that fewer people can access, the question becomes not only what knowledge survives, but who gets to study it. A course elsewhere is not an equivalent opportunity for someone with caring responsibilities, a job or no means to relocate. Institutional “efficiency” can mean transferring the cost of lost provision to students and communities with the least capacity to absorb it.
For colleagues, this uncertainty is itself a burden. They must plan teaching without knowing who will remain, reassure students without reliable answers, and pursue growth while the means of achieving it are withheld. Commitment becomes a subsidy: staff work longer because they cannot bear to abandon students or watch a subject disappear. The budget records a saving; the person absorbs the cost. Wellbeing cannot be restored by asking people to become more resilient to conditions the institution continues to impose.
The demand should therefore be for cumulative accountability: disclose what successive decisions do to staffing, provision, and the possibility of recovery, not merely what each saves. Explain which subjects are being supported, which are being allowed to contract and why. If a university intends to retreat from a discipline, it should defend that decision publicly. It should not be allowed to remove the conditions of survival and then describe the resulting collapse as proof that the department could never survive.
Shahenda Shehata | Comment | 12/11/26