Subscribe

Briefings

Daily BriefingEvery weekday · by 8amHigher education's essential morning read.Monday BriefingWeekly · MondaysThe full week ahead in HE policy.Friday ReviewWeekly · Friday lunchtimesWhat you need to know about the week just gone.

Newsletters & more

HE InfluencePolitics and policy and the way the sector is seen.HE CounselNewGovernance, law and regulation for anyone following legal developments.Policy RadarThe monthly live policy briefing – watch live or catch the replay on the portal.

Services

Wonkhe PassFull access for your whole institution.Wonkhe SUs PassFor students' unions – briefings, recordings and training.Free briefingThe Monday Briefing, Lite edition – free.
About Us+
About WonkhePeopleOur partnersWrite for WonkheContact us
Events
Latest+
Explore the whole archiveDataWonkhe researchLong readsAnalysisCommentWonk Corner
Podcast
SUs
Thursday 24 September 2026Home of the higher education debate

Copyright © 2026 Thesis House Ltd.

Wonkhe is published by Thesis House Ltd, registered in England and Wales (no. 08784934), 31–35 Kirby Street, London EC1N 8TE.

  • Moderation policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
Thesis
David Kernohan

David Kernohan

David Kernohan is Deputy Editor of Wonkhe

This article is more than 5 years old

Wonk Corner11/03/21 · 12:56
Tags
  • Access & WP
  • Covid-19

This article is more than 5 years old

Wonk Corner|11/03/21 · 12:56

What did students get their parents for Christmas? Apparently, not Covid-19

The student travel window saw thousands return from halls of residence to their parents house. It was, at the time, seen as something as a risk.

David Kernohan
David Kernohan is Deputy Editor of Wonkhe

In the charming way that we all became experts in epidemiology in 2020, everyone knew that there was loads of Covid-19 around universities late last year - so students coming home would likely infect everyone they came into contact with - driving the virus round the country.

It was for this reason that Michelle Donelan and Gavin Williamson invented the Student Travel Window, mass testing, and advice for students to avoid public transport and enclosed spaces where possible. The mass testing, arguably, sparked the English education sector's increasingly magical belief in the efficacy of lateral flow testing to ensure setting specific safety.

Today saw the release of a more recent cut of TUNDRA (basically POLAR young participation data but removing some unusual school type outliers), covering participation between 2012 and 2016. It doesn't exactly predict the proportion of HE students originally domiciled in each (MSOA) area, but it's the best data we've got. And, as it happens, the PHE dashboard data offers us a week of Covid-19 case numbers and rates for MSOA starting on 25 December.

[Full screen]

There is no correlation between participation rates and case numbers (or case rates). R squared is about 0.06 - we'd only start thinking about a relationship between two variables at around 0.7. I've included an UTLA filter to let you narrow down to particular areas.

There was clearly a lot of Covid-19 in Essex at the time, but participation rates had nothing to do with it. Shenfiled and Hutton Mount (TUNDRA: 66.4 per cent) saw 1,448 cases per 100k that week - Bocking (TUNDRA: 22.5 per cent) saw 1,372.

Bonus plot

People like maps, so here's a TUNDRA map (quintiles as colours) showing the location of HE campuses. If you stumble across a grey area (ha!) that's because there weren't enough people in that MSOA to safely calculate the rate.

[Full screen]