It’s a tricky thing, inflation.
Not only are there two measures (one widely discredited but still used for students and universities – RPI), there’s also the question of when you take a reading.
Except in higher education fees and funding land, a reading isn’t used at all. A projection by the OBR is.
I’ve written endlessly about the way in which the OBR’s eternal medium-term optimism on inflation means that student maintenance in England keeps being uprated short, and compounds when DfE fails to correct for errors.
But it’s now an issue hitting universities too.
Today’s inevitable news from Cardiff Bay – minister Cefin Campbell confirming that Welsh Government will allow fees to rise by the same increase about to apply in England – reminds us of how faulty the rise figure is.
The method is in a footnote to DfE’s impact assessment for this year’s English fee regulations – the uplift is the OBR’s RPIX forecast for the first quarter of the calendar year that falls within that academic year. So the £10,050 cap for 2027/28 rests on a guess, made in November 2025, about prices in January to March 2028.
We can already check how that went the first time round. When the cap moved from £9,250 to £9,535 for 2025/26, the 3.1 per cent uplift was the OBR’s autumn 2024 forecast for RPIX in the first quarter of 2026. The ONS now tells us that RPIX actually ran at 3.8 per cent in that quarter.
Had the cap tracked that outturn it would have been around £9,600 in 2025/26 – and carried forward through the 2.71 per cent and 2.68 per cent rises now on the statute book, it would reach around £10,125 in 2027/28 rather than £10,050. That’s roughly £75 per student per year lost to a single forecasting miss, and nothing in the system ever claws it back.
The next miss is already coming into view. The 2.71 per cent rise for 2026/27 is supposed to match RPIX in the first quarter of 2027 – but RPIX was running at 4.1 per cent in the year to October 2026, up from 2.9 per cent in June. That whopping increase in the energy price cap that’s coming is likely to push it even higher.
The 2.68 per cent for 2027/28 was nodded through in March on the strength of that November 2025 forecast, with no mechanism to revisit it if the OBR’s view of 2028 changes – so a figure set more than two years ahead of the quarter it is meant to match is now fixed in law.
It hasn’t stopped ministers in Westminster from treating indexation as job done. The original 2024 announcement promised fees would “rise in line with inflation, helping put universities on a secure footing”. Asked about universities at risk from frozen fees, Josh MacAlister insisted that fees had risen “in line with forecast inflation for 2025/26, 2026/27, and 2027/28.” Jacqui Smith has told peers that the sector “needs a secure financial footing,” which is why the department chose to raise caps “for the next two years, in line with inflation”. And DfE has gone on to cite “our decision to raise tuition fees annually in line with inflation” as proof of its commitment to the sector’s finances.
Notice how the word “forecast” comes and goes. Fees that rise in line with inflation and fees that rise in line with a forecast of it are not the same thing.
To be fair, Campbell’s statement doesn’t mention inflation – it says the cap will mirror the approach taken in England, which means Welsh providers inherit a number built on a 2025 guess about 2028 prices, with its baked-in miss from 2025/26 carried along for the ride.
As such, you might have thought that a minister presiding over an £81m sector deficit would be railing against a formula that short-changes his universities. Instead Campbell is far more sheepish about raising fees at all – it is “not a decision any Minister wants to make,” the sector’s finances leave him “with little option,” and he frets about additional borrowing for students.
That’s the same Campbell who, from the opposition benches in 2024, warned that extra cash for the sector wouldn’t touch the sides of the shortfall – and who now finds himself defending an estimated £18m that touches them even less, without pointing out that the uplift generating it was set too low in the first place.
Why else might Campbell be keen to not say the word inflation? Well, there’s no announcement from England or Wales yet on maintenance – last year Wales switched to CPI rather than the Diamond-era minimum wage anchor – but even then, as I noted last year, its 2.0 per cent rise for 2026/27 used an OBR projection for the first quarter of 2027 while actual CPI was running at 3.8 per cent. Providers get the higher measure and students get the lower one, and both get it via a forecast with a habit of coming in short.
Nobody expects the OBR to be clairvoyant. But a system that never reconciles forecast with outturn means every miss gets locked in, and when the misses mostly fall the same way, real fee income and real student support both drift downwards. If the Prendergast review is serious about a sustainable settlement for Wales, this farce ought to be in the mix.