The agreement is not conditional on a tuition fee agreement.
The deal is done.
On cross-border trade, on food standards, and on the much-trailed youth mobility scheme, the UK and EU have reached agreement.
There are other negations to follow, which include the issue of tuition fees: both for EU student studying in the UK, and UK students studying in the EU. There had been pre-briefing that the rest of the deal was conditional on an agreement being reached on fees: but the language used at the press conference suggested this was not the case.
The language on fees in the agreement itself reads:
The EU and UK will […] work towards a supplementing agreement to the Trade and Cooperation Agreement on tuition fees for EU students in the UK and for UK students in the EU. The Agreement will apply to all students from the other Party irrespective of the immigration pathway. The aim is to increase opportunities for students to study in each other’s territories. We will conclude the negotiations within six months from the date of the summit.
It clearly remains an aspiration, but with legislation already on the way in the UK and agreements already reached on youth mobility (to go alongside the previous return of the UK to Erasmus plus) there has been no suggestion that agreement is a pre-requisite. It is striking that both sides are open both to incremental agreements alongside the possibility for “informal brainstorming” ahead of more fundamental moves towards wider agreements. A “supplementing agreement” is very much another increment, not a stumbling block.
The language in the main agreement on the Youth Experience Scheme (yes, that’s “YES”) is significant for the sector in itself. From 2030, 100,000 young people (between 18 and 31) from the EU and the UK respectively will be able to “reside for up to three years to engage in activities such as work, studies, au-pairing, volunteering, or simply travelling” – and this comes alongside a very broad commitment to “further increasing opportunities for studying, as well as other activities under Erasmus+ across the UK and the EU.” And it continues:
The UK and the EU jointly recognise the importance of our shared strength in higher education to equip our young people with the skills they need to support economic growth and European competitiveness.
The YES is visa-based – with anyone taking part required to apply initially for a (paid for) two year visa under the scheme which can be extended for a further year. This would give participants the right to live, work, and study in up to three member states over the a three-year period. There is a requirement that EU participants in the UK will pay the Immigration Health Surcharge at a discounted rate (75 per cent of the full charge: so around £582 each year rather than the £776 currently charged for youth mobility and student entrants) and must have comprehensive health care coverage. As with other visas there will be no recourse to welfare funds, and applicants must have sufficient funds to support themselves. And as with most student visas, dependents are not permitted.
As such, it feels like the YES could well replace the student visa for EU applicants to undergraduate and taught postgraduate courses: it offers wider opportunity to work while studying, or to stay in country if they decide not to continue on their course. Though young people using the scheme are asked to state their intended activity, there will be broad labour market access (with exact terms to be defined) and there does not appear to be a mechanism to hold young people to their stated “intended primary activity.” And it is likely (given the health surcharge discount) to be cheaper overall. This alone could be enough to expand EU student numbers slightly: something that could well be argued to offset any future measures on tuition fees.
More detail on YES will likely arrive in legislation due as early as next week. It is not clear when we would hear more on tuition fees, but it is clear that discussions are clearly continuing.