Recommendations include end to the Treasury top-slice, payments for training providers – oh, and ending the levy as we know it
The first part of Alan Milburn’s NEET review had some strong words about England’s apprenticeship system, which – in his view – had been “captured by the economic logic of upskilling existing employees” and thus was overlooking young people.
His final report’s headline policy recommendations were widely trailed in the press, and were very much stick not carrot: obliging employers who wanted to offer apprenticeships to those aged 25 and above to fund a quarter of of the training cost themselves. That is, in addition to the levy contributions they make – many employers already thought they were funding apprenticeships themselves.
It’s a rather simplistic approach: in reality, employers don’t weigh up whether to spend levy funds on existing employees or new starters, notice that the costs involved are the same, and then plump for the former. The two options represent significantly different approaches to workforce development, and you can be forgiven for assuming that companies will simply spend less on upskilling current staff without then rushing to hire new apprentices out of Britain’s NEET population.
But the substance of Milburn’s proposals in fact go much further and – if the government follows through on them – represent an enormous shake-up to how the system works. For one thing, he calls for a “significant scaling up” of financial support for both employers and training providers, to encourage them to take on young apprentices. His suggestion is that providers could be compensated to the tune of £2,000:
The provider payment rewards the organisations that generate opportunities, engage employers, recruit young labour market entrants and support them to completion.
This would actually see the government paying for apprenticeships to happen. This shouldn’t seem such a dramatic shift, given how much ministers go on about their love for apprenticeships, but Milburn is telling the state to put its money where its mouth is if it wants to change the system – and not just endlessly fiddle about with eligibility and try to browbeat businesses into taking on new hires.
Speaking of the Treasury actually coughing up, Milburn’s report is clear that the levy topslice – the income to the Exchequer which does not find its way to the apprenticeship budget or the devolved nations, put at £460m in 2026–27 – needs to end:
This is a significant fiscal choice. But a government serious about rebuilding apprenticeships as a route for young people has to fund the ambition it sets.
The most radical change, and one where it’s hard not to be sceptical about its prospects, is skated over quite quickly in the report – but it represents an enormous, long-term seachange in the system. Currently employers who pay the levy have an account with a balance, and need to either use it or lose it (or transfer it). Milburn calls for this to be done away with, essentially, saying that over time notional employer levy balances and levy transfers should be replaced by a “direct funding model aligned to employer demand and government priorities,” without specific recruitment limits according to size of a company’s levy pot.
Essentially, he concludes that the way the levy has been set up outsourced decisions about the size and shape of the apprenticeship system to employers, and they got it wrong – for reasons which are the government’s fault rather than theirs:
The Levy represented a new tax imposed on employers by central government. The unspoken compromise was that employers were then given control over how it was spent, with limited government direction. As a result, individual businesses have made entirely rational decisions, which have often prioritised using Levy funding to retrain older and current workers over recruiting and training younger workers.
In language which may be reminiscent to those who call for the government to think properly about what the HE sector should look like, Milburn wants – longer-term – for ministers to think harder what apprenticeships should be funded, and where, and for whom, rather than leaving the system demand-led.
What the review doesn’t speak to is which training providers will be at the centre of the push for more youth apprenticeships. In the event that there are financial incentives on offer, it strikes me that it is even more important to ensure that the system does not become a scramble for starts. Instead, as I’ve argued previously, colleges and universities should be at the heart of any new system.
The next question is how far the government goes in following through on the detail, rather than the broad sentiments. Secretary of State Pat McFadden was very positive about the latter in his statement to MPs this afternoon, and a white paper is promised. At the same time, his remarks were couched in the government’s preferred rhetoric about continuing to “tilt” the apprenticeship system towards young people. But Milburn’s prescription isn’t to keep on tilting this way and that – it’s to upend.