The minister suggests that sector finances may, in fact, be some way down in her in tray
From the English higher education finance system being under active review, to the issue sitting at the top of Lucy Powell’s famous in-tray, the Department for Education has generally parried the frequent calls for an independent review with suggestions that officials have an eye on things in some, less public, way.
On one level, this is likely true. Civil servants, after all, tend to have an eye over everything – while, in the classical formulation, ministers decide which issues require policy action and which do not. But the frequent references to departmental thinking about higher education finance from dispatch boxes in both Houses of Parliament have suggested something more active and more formal than this null reading.
Skills Minister Jacqui Smith is a talented communicator who chooses her words, and her overall approach, with some care. She has faced criticism for providing pre-recorded video appearances at sector conferences during the early part of the year, but has lately been more likely to attend in person. Her approach to the sector is conversational, and this works better the more spontaneous and natural it feels: she is always keen to take questions from the audience, which at a higher education conference means dealing with a wide range of questions ranging from the technical to the political.
The perennial issue of funding and the much requested review must have been something she expected to be pushed on at the Independent Higher Education conference (held on Wednesday in London), and the inevitable question did arise. She started by noting that this was an issue that many were asking her about, but then drew an interesting distinction around who was making all the noise:
this is something that has become of much more concern to graduates than it is to those accessing higher education.
Of course, the question of funding has many aspects – but the original audience question directly dealt with the constraints that the current funding settlement puts on innovation in provision at higher education providers. To Smith, the issue is linked primarily to graduate repayments – there was no language at all on fee levels (even though she could, and has previously referred to, the inflationary increases in the fee cap.
For the minister, changes to graduate repayments are expensive
In the end, this comes down to fees. If we want to do a major reform of student finance, let nobody be under any misapprehension that it will cost a normal amount.
And the government has other approaches to addressing the financial squeeze that graduates are feeling – making the unfairness of the loan repayment system into one aspect of a generic “cost of living” pressure.
“There are set of priorities here, and I think there are different ways to support people who are finding challenges in their cost of living linked to repayments of student loans than there are, and those are things that we’re doing, which are housing access, a whole range of other health things, a whole range of things that help. If you if you want to control the student finance, I think you really have to think very fundamentally about spend an enormous amount of money on subsidising Into higher education, which is then taken away from other parts of the skills sector
So there we are. The government will support graduates in the same way as it supports everyone else, rather than take action on a particular cost pressure it is placing on graduates. To address the system directly would be expensive, and would take funding away from the government’s clear priorities elsewhere.