Published on the same day as Alan Milburn’s final report on young people and work, two new DWP studies of 18 to 24 year-olds claiming health and disability benefits paint a bleak picture of what happens when some of the young people at the centre of his plan try to study.
Milburn’s report doesn’t cite DWP’s survey analysis of 293 young claimants or NatCen’s 40 in-depth interviews with young people who are NEET or their benefits appointees – the only Work Aspirations research in its footnotes is the 2025 interim findings for claimants of all ages.
That matters because taking up education can put a young person’s benefits at risk. Milburn’s welfare proposals and the Lifelong Learning Entitlement (LLE), which is about to replace student finance in England, leave that problem unresolved.
Only 6 per cent of the young claimants in the survey hold a degree or equivalent, against 17 per cent of all 16 to 24 year-olds – the age groups and survey definitions differ, but the report says the gap holds against similar ages in the Annual Population Survey.
Nearly half of those not in work worry that they wouldn’t get their benefits back if they tried a job and it didn’t work out.
In the interviews, none of the few participants who made it to university completed their course, and every one of them put that down to health rather than the academic work.
One benefits appointee describes ringing the halls accommodation officer by week four to ask them to check on their son, who turned out to be unable to get into bed and hadn’t eaten properly, and the move from structured school to “flexible university settings” is singled out as a point where people fall away.
Others never got that far. Some chose paid work over education because they had no other income, some said earlier access to the Personal Independence Payment (PIP) would have kept them in education, and one young parent, according to her appointee, feared that “if I go back to college I’m going to lose my benefits”.
One participant planning to return to higher education is looking to the Open University, having concluded that “face-to-face university is just not for me”.
The DWP research points to clearer, personalised advice, but for full-time study the fear is largely accurate. Under regulation 12 of the Universal Credit rules, someone on a full-time course is “receiving education” and mostly can’t claim. One disability-related exception requires a qualifying disability benefit and a limited capability for work decision made before the course started.
Milburn’s answer is a Youth Allowance at the under-25 Universal Credit rate, with a higher rate for those living independently. He would abolish the Work Capability Assessment and health top-up, and replace PIP for under-25s with an Additional Cost Allowance. A separate, more generous payment would support those with severe and complex needs. The Timms review has yet to make its final recommendations on PIP.
“University study where appropriate” is on the menu under his Opportunity Guarantee, but the Youth Allowance is described as covering the period while young people are “working towards earning a wage or moving into education or training”, and the report never says whether it carries on once they get there.
The analytical annex gives little reassurance. Its modelling uses forecasts of the Universal Credit caseload, including a higher allowance for those living independently and a work allowance for all under-25s. It does not set out a change to the rules that mostly shut out full-time students.
Without a Work Capability Assessment for under-25s, it is also unclear how a disabled young person could obtain the limited capability for work decision needed for the disability-related route onto Universal Credit as a full-time student. Unless the rules change, the guarantee could offer a university place while making it a financial gamble – the fear the DWP interviews record.
The LLE, which funds courses and modules starting from January 2027 and which Milburn calls “an important building block” of his digital “Open College”, makes all of this more complicated.
Under DfE’s guidance, the LLE no longer has separate rules for full-time and part-time students. Maintenance is cut in proportion to the credits taken in a course year, and for the first time it’s available on approved modules as well as full courses, as long as someone is studying at least 30 credits in the year. Universal Credit still hinges on the distinction the LLE abolishes, because the exclusion in regulation 12 only bites on a “full-time” course.
So a student who is not full-time may be able to claim, but then the student income rules kick in. Under regulations 68 to 71, a student who could get a maintenance loan “by taking reasonable steps” is treated as having it, whether or not they take it out. The maximum amount is counted, without a reduction for parental income, and comes off Universal Credit pound for pound after a £110 monthly disregard. DWP ignores the special support element, which students getting PIP qualify for, but the maintenance element still counts.
So as the LLE extends maintenance to modules, a young person on benefits who takes one may find part of their benefit replaced by a loan. Milburn says nothing about whether his new Youth Allowance would work the same way, though as a means-tested allowance set at the Universal Credit rate it’s hard to see why it wouldn’t.
The in-person rule adds another snag. The interviews find online learning working for young people with social anxiety, chronic fatigue and agoraphobia, and Milburn wants a national digital college, but under the LLE, as now, distance learners only get maintenance if a disability stops them attending.
That makes the money depend on showing that a disability is the reason – in a report whose health chapter complains that diagnosis has become “the key that unlocks help” and proposes squeezing the private assessment market.
Milburn’s annual step-off qualifications would mean the young people in the DWP interviews who left university after a year had something to show for it, which would be a real improvement for a group who currently leave with debt and nothing else.
But someone who steps off without moving into work or training becomes NEET. Milburn proposes an adviser, a Participation Plan and a duty to engage, with sanctions as a last resort. Expectations would be suspended during serious acute illness or treatment. It is less clear how a plan would treat someone recovering from a health-related withdrawal from their course who wants to return, or what would happen to their benefit when they did.
In principle you can see where Milburn is coming from. Ending the binary judgement about whether a young person can work, and building support before cutting benefits, beats another round of reassessment.
But a system that wants young people to “earn or learn” needs DfE’s rules on when maintenance is paid and DWP’s rules on when it counts against benefits to be designed together. At the moment the LLE will split maintenance into modules while the benefits system still asks whether a course is full-time, and it remains unclear whether the Youth Allowance would continue when a young person takes up the education it is supposed to lead to.
Milburn wants a statutory Youth Opportunity Test applied to big tax, spending and regulatory decisions, and the boundary between student finance and benefits would be a good place to start. Test the rules together for someone taking up, pausing or returning to study – because a university place is no guarantee if taking it remains a financial gamble.