Milburn’s proposals are radical, but the thinking on higher education falls short on what would be needed for the sector to play a vital role. David Kernohan has a first read

The second part of Alan Milburn’s report into “young people and work” is as resolutely focused as you might expect on the UK’s one million young people not in education, employment, or training (NEETs).
While part one mapped out the dimensions and proportions of the NEET problem, part two puts in place numerous, often very radical, long term solutions. It is very much the kind of landmark report that could set the tone for government interventions across health, social security, and education in the ten years to come.
The starting point is eloquently set out in Milburns’ foreword:
Among the many hundreds of young people I have met in the last year I have not found a single one of them who wanted to be NEET. Not one.
Implicit within this is that there is not one single cause, or even a handful of common contributions, to NEET status. As part one of the report demonstrated, there are characteristics and demographic determinants that make some young people more likely to be NEET than others: and it is also true that once someone becomes NEET it has an impact on the rest of their lives.
There are many current systems and programmes that aim to support young people into employment. While some have seen an amount of localised success, Milburn’s starting point is that nothing we currently have is working at the scale necessary to deal with the problem: a problem is described as the “new phenomenon of youth detachment.”
Although it is perhaps not that new a phenomenon. The NEET rate has hovered north of ten per cent for the last quarter of a century – a rate that has slowed growth, lowered productivity, and had a measurable impact on gross domestic product. There are, however, current and oncoming risks – changes in the experiences of growing into adulthood, changes in the nature of work – that could make the situation even worse.
The report puts forward a national ambition: every young person should be learning, earning, or actively participating. By 2035, NEET rates should have fallen to around 5 per cent – with a first milestone ensuring that no 16 to 17 year old is NEET (something that, legally, shouldn’t be happening anyway – there are at least 57,000 of them in England).
Each young person needs a particular blend of support – for some it will be simple practical measures like gaining experience or access to transport, for others housing or mental health may be a root problem. While Milburn is clear that some disabled young people will require intensive and sustained support (in some cases where participation is not a realistic expectation this would be long-term in nature) the central message is on support towards employment.
The framing is of a reprofiling of funding from welfare to support, with a multi-agency (indeed, a multi-department) flavour. State support will help employers create first jobs, apprenticeships, and work experience. Education providers at each stage will be judged on what we might call “progression” – whether young people move on to further learning (be that academic or technical in nature) or employment. The NHS gains a preventative role in youth mental health, while the welfare system manages a statutory entitlement to an individual participation plan, with tailored support via a place-based Youth Opportunity Service (YOS).
There is a cost to all this. Milburn calls for £500m up front, with the expansion of future provision funded via changes to the benefit system – the idea is the changes and the new support work in tandem to reprofile ostensibly the same funds with a new focus.
To be clear, this is a good report proposing broadly sensible evidence based changes to a complex set of systems and expectations. However, the treatment of higher education in the report leaves a lot to be desired.
Although one in seven of those described as NEET have a university degree, the majority of these – in contrast to those without higher level qualifications – do not remain NEET for long. There are interventions that could help smooth the transition between a degree and a job, but there is no specific attention paid to structural changes in graduate employment.
The government’s last detailed policy statement about the sector was the Skills White Paper last autumn, and Milburn draws from a lot of the same sources to produce some surprisingly similar recommendations. We retain, for example, the binary divide between “academic” and “vocational” routes, without any suggestion that the majority of university courses are actually vocationally-orientated. Universities should focus on employability – they do. Schools – despite numerous interventions to ensure they do other things – apparently just funnel people onto UCAS. Which doesn’t display student outcomes data for courses (it absolutely does).
Apprenticeships should “rival university as a mainstream destination for school leavers” with around 35 per cent of each cohort starting an apprenticeship by the age of 25. There’s little to back up this near doubling in young apprenticeship provision, just like there is nothing that would drive the required change in achievements (people actually completing apprenticeships should go from 65 per cent to 80 per cent – and even that 65 per cent feels a stretch when the OfS numeric threshold for UG apprenticeship completions sits at just 55 per cent). The apprenticeship levy would regain the current treasury topslice, and youth apprenticeships should be 100 per cent funded by government from levy proceeds, with a consequent decline in support for older apprentices. What this doesn’t address is delivery capacity, and while the increase in hiring payments and incentives is clearly welcome, it is unlikely to cover the cost of actually running an apprenticeship.
A national digital Open College – an “Open University for skills”, apparently – will use AI to help people navigate and accumulate credit from courses offered through colleges, universities, and other providers. Employers and other private investors would contribute to the costs of such courses, and this assemblage would also see the Lifelong Learning Entitlement (essentially learner’s own money repaid through the loan system) as an “important building block”.
While these are all laudable aims, we are missing a couple of implementation stages. The UK doesn’t have a national credit transfer framework that covers even higher education, let alone FE and private providers. The development of such a framework would be as key to these plans as it is to the LLE, but Milburn is silent on how this actually happens.
Curiously, the report does make a fair case for higher education reform more generally:
The NEET crisis should help prompt a strategic rethink about the role of HE within the wider tertiary system and how public resources are allocated across competing priorities. Over recent years the financial incentive and regulatory regime for higher education has tilted universities towards competing for students rather than a much stronger focus on employability. If universities are to play their part in addressing the youth employment crisis, a shift is needed
We don’t get the shift that is needed based on that analysis. There should – in another repeat, this time from HTQ days – be an attempt to “rebalance provision” towards level 4 and 5 skills, and a range of “step-off” qualifications (established by the government?) for those who leave HE after a year and may want to build towards another qualification in future. FE colleges should be able to deliver HE with greater ease and simplified regulatory requirements – a recommendation that appears not to have noticed that we are currently clamping down on academic partnerships and making it harder to deliver courses on behalf of other providers, though the report does shoehorn in a paragraph on low quality courses later that at least mentions it (alongside committing Milburn to basic English proficiency as a precondition for student loan access).
A similar criticism could be raised against the call for more “satellite campuses” in cold spots – a partnership arrangement is the obvious way for a cash-strapped HE providers to do this and yet recent DfE and OfS moves add more red tape to this process.
And what are we to make of the idea that:
A degree in one institution should meet a standard that can be understood and trusted alongside a degree in another. Such a change should be tested with the sector before wider implementation.
The quality assurance system in England does not allow us to do that – and indeed the HE regulator has been busy either stripping away (peer academic review, oversight of internal processes, external examiners) or ignoring (professional statutory and regulatory bodies) the vestigial elements that exist to allow for that kind of comparability. Again, no details on implementation, but we are to hope that plans could extend beyond asking nicely at the Universities UK conference.

Debbie McVitty | Policy Watch | 5/11/26

Team Wonkhe | Policy Watch | 28/10/26

Debbie McVitty | Policy Watch | 22/10/26

Jim Dickinson | Policy Watch | 20/10/26

Jim Dickinson | Policy Watch | 12/10/26

David Kernohan | Policy Watch | 18/09/26